The Potential for Subordinate Predator Release in Terrestrial Mammalian Carnivore Assemblages
Open Access
- 3 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Mammal Review
Abstract
Mesopredator release occurs when the decline of a dominant predator leads to an increase in a mid‐sized predator due to reduced top‐down pressure, often triggering cascading ecological effects. However, predator–predator interactions are complex and not strictly size‐dependent. We aimed to systematically review the evidence for suppressive relationships among terrestrial carnivores to assess the potential for subordinate predator release across different species and ecological contexts. We conducted a systematic literature search up to February 2023, adapting previous frameworks. Studies were included if they demonstrated one carnivore suppressing another's population, which we used as a proxy for release potential. We categorised studies based on geographic location, species involved, methodology, and strength of evidence, ranking support from strength 1 (weakest) to strength 3 (strongest). We found evidence for potential subordinate predator release across various size differences, challenging the traditional apex–mesopredator dichotomy. Inconsistencies in how authors perceived suppression highlight the need for caution in defining trophic roles in complex systems. Canids and felids were equally represented as dominant carnivores in studies, but canids overwhelmingly occupied the subordinate role. This pattern may reflect their broader dietary niches and adaptability, but could also result from geographic research biases, particularly in the USA and Australia. Our findings emphasise the need for more diverse, context‐dependent studies to disentangle ecological mechanisms from research bias. Clarifying terminology and trophic classifications will enhance understanding of predator interactions and their ecological impacts. Future research should focus on collating contradictory evidence to better understand the context dependency of intraguild interactions and analysing the strength of species responses to inform conservation and management strategies.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- The fox who cried wolf: A keywords and literature trend analysis on the phenomenon of mesopredator releaseEcological Complexity, 2021
- Fear of the dark? A mesopredator mitigates large carnivore risk through nocturnality, but humans moderate the interactionBehavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 2020
- Coupled population dynamics of two Neotropical marsupials driven by mesopredator's abundancePopulation Ecology, 2019
- Large carnivore impacts are context-dependentFood Webs, 2017
- Where can wolves live and how can we live with them?Biological Conservation, 2017
- In the absence of a “landscape of fear”: How lions, hyenas, and cheetahs coexistEcology and Evolution, 2016
- Data Analysis2016
- Competitive release and area effectsEcological Complexity, 2012
- Intraguild predation and mesopredator release effect on long-lived preyEcological Modelling, 2009
- Carnivore body size: Ecological and taxonomic correlatesOecologia, 1985