Fine‐needle aspiration of renal cell carcinoma: Is accurate Fuhrman grading possible on cytologic material?
Authors:
- Gregory A. HoslerGHGregory A. Hosler
- Piotr KuleszaPKPiotr Kulesza
- Syed Z. AliSASyed Z. Ali
- 11 February 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Diagnostic Cytopathology
- Vol. 39 (3) , 168-171
Abstract
The Fuhrman grading system of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) consists of four grades based on nuclear size/contour and nucleolar conspicuousness. Fuhrman grading of histpathologic material is an independent prognostic parameter for RCC. Although widely used in surgical pathology, Fuhrman grading is not routinely performed on cytologic material. Thirty‐three cases of renal fine needle aspirations (FNAs) with histologically proven RCC were retrieved from the cytopathology archives at Johns Hopkins Hospital. Fuhrman grade was determined independently and blindly by three faculty cytopathologists and compared with the Fuhrman grade of the subsequent surgical pathology specimen. The 33 resection specimens had the following Fuhrman grades: 0/33, grade I; 24/33 (73%), grade II; 9/33 (27%), grade III; and 0/33, grade IV. After Fuhrman grading was applied to the FNA material, diagnostic sensitivity was 83% for grade II versus 44% for grade III. The specificity and accuracy were 50 and 75%, respectively, for grade II versus 100% and 84% for grade III. Diagnostic sensitivity for grade II tumors ranged from 38 to 83%, grade III 44–62%. Diagnostic specificity for grade II tumors ranged from 50 to 78%, grade III 80–100%. Accuracy ranged from 48 to 75% for grade II and 75–87% for grade III. Using a two‐tier grading model, accuracy improved to 84.2%. In our experience, Fuhrman grading of FNA specimens yielded variable results. There was only moderate agreement between cytopathologists, with an overall tendency to undergrade the tumor when compared with the resection specimen. Averaging the participants' grading and using a two‐tier instead of four‐tier system improved overall performance. Diagn. Cytopathol.2011;39:168–171.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fuhrman Grading is not Appropriate for Chromophobe Renal Cell CarcinomaAmerican Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2007
- Original and reviewed nuclear grading according to the Fuhrman systemCancer, 2004
- Cytopathologic grading of hepatocellular carcinoma on fine-needle aspirationCancer, 2004
- Prognostic significance of morphologic parameters in renal cell carcinomaInternational Journal Of Clinical Practice, 2004
- Comparison of Standardized and Nonstandardized Nuclear Grade of Renal Cell Carcinoma to Predict Outcome Among 2,042 PatientsAmerican Journal of Clinical Pathology, 2002
- Estimating the world cancer burden: Globocan 2000International Journal of Cancer, 2001
- Rising Incidence of Renal Cell Cancer in the United StatesJAMA, 1999
- A comparative analysis of grading systems in renal adenocarcinomaHistopathology, 1994
- Diagnosis of renal cell carcinoma: value of fine-needle aspiration cytology in patients with metastases or contraindications to nephrectomy.American Journal of Roentgenology, 1993
- Prognostic significance of morphologic parameters in renal cell carcinomaAmerican Journal of Surgical Pathology, 1982