Is Reading Comprehension Taken for Granted? An Analysis of Austrian Textbooks in Fourth and Sixth Grade
Open Access
- 19 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Technology, Knowledge and Learning
- Vol. 26 (2) , 383-405
Abstract
The range of teaching materials now available is becoming increasingly diverse. Despite this, however, the use and influence of textbooks in teaching still remains very high. When instructing reading comprehension, teachers often use textbooks as the basis for teaching in language lessons. Establishing a good match between textbooks and the skills to be acquired is therefore essential. In this paper, I investigate whether textbooks used in Austrian schools can adequately support the teaching of reading comprehension skills. Since reading comprehension is the basis for acquiring knowledge in all subjects, science textbooks are examined in addition to (German) language lesson textbooks. Thus, the content pages of four language textbooks and four science textbooks for fourth and sixth grade were analysed in terms of five different categories, i.e. general structural setup, learning goals, text types, text structures, and activities. The results reveal clear variations with respect to learning goals in language textbooks. For example, the extent to which reading comprehension is addressed ranges from 13.64 to 69.70%, depending on the book used. Although not addressed as a learning goal in the science textbooks, reading comprehension is often presupposed, especially in sixth grade. While the instruction of reading comprehension ought to entail coverage of reading strategies, this is often neglected, or only dealt with indirectly. Given the diversity of textbooks analysed, it seems all the more important to stress that teachers should: 1) clarify the goals and teaching strategies of a book before using it, 2) become aware of strategies that support the development of students' reading comprehension, and 3) use textbooks as a complementary (and not sole) tool to support reading comprehension in all subjects.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Graz
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Teachers’ use of textbooks in the digital ageCogent Education, 2015
- How to Teach Expository Text Structure to Facilitate Reading ComprehensionThe Reading Teacher, 2011
- Do Textbooks Used in University Reading Education Courses Conform to the Instructional Recommendations of the National Reading Panel?Journal of Learning Disabilities, 2009
- Nature of science as depicted in Turkish biology textbooksScience Education, 2008
- Development of word reading fluency and spelling in a consistent orthography: An 8-year follow-up.Journal of Educational Psychology, 2008
- Diagnosis and Treatment of Reading Disabilities Based on the Component Model of ReadingJournal of Learning Disabilities, 2008
- Learning to Teach with Mathematics Textbooks: How Preservice Teachers Interpret and Use Curriculum MaterialsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2006
- The Acquisition of Reading Comprehension Skill2005
- Can middle‐school science textbooks help students learn important ideas? Findings from project 2061's curriculum evaluation study: Life scienceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2004
- The Organization of Prose and Its Effects on MemoryThe American Journal of Psychology, 1978