A comparison of methods to evaluate the behavior of finite element models with rough surfaces
Abstract
Finite element (FE) modeling of rough surfaces is becoming increasingly common. However, the quality of the assumptions being made in these models, and thus the quality of the models themselves, is often unclear. Decisions about the geometry of the surface to be modeled, including the size of the surface to be modeled, the lateral resolution of the measured surface data to be used, and the formulation of the probabilistic surface to be used, can have a significant effect on a model's behavior. Similarly, varying model parameters, including the FE mesh density, can change the results by a factor of three or more. This work examines some of the metrics that can be used to evaluate the influence of these assumptions and parameters on FE models with rough surfaces and discusses the relative merits of each option. In particular, qualitative comparison of result plots, quantitative comparison and convergence of results parameters, qualitative and quantitative comparison of distributions of result values over various model dimensions, and more sophisticated comparison techniques inspired by image and signal processing are discussed. SCANNING 33: 353–369, 2011.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Considerations for the incorporation of measured surfaces in finite element modelsScanning, 2010
- Experimental Study of the Performance of Static Seals Based on Measurements of Real Contact Area Using Thin Polycarbonate FilmsJournal of Tribology, 2010
- Asperity Creep Measured by the Reflection of Ultrasound at Rough Surface ContactJournal of Tribology, 2009
- Finite-element analysis of contact between elastic self-affine surfacesPhysical Review E, 2004
- Ultrasonic measurements of nominal contact area and contact pressure in a wheel-rail systemProceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part F: Journal of Rail and Rapid Transit, 2000
- Modeling Effects of Material Properties and Three-Dimensional Surface Roughness on Thermal Barrier CoatingsMRS Proceedings, 2000
- A Numerical Three-Dimensional Model for the Contact of Rough Surfaces by Variational PrincipleJournal of Tribology, 1996
- A simple error estimator and adaptive procedure for practical engineerng analysisInternational Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 1987
- Analysis of Optimal Finite-Element Meshes in R 1Mathematics of Computation, 1979
- The Static Coefficient of Friction and the Area of ContactProceedings of the Physical Society. Section B, 1950