Risk‐stratification tools for emergency department patients with syncope: A systematic review and meta‐analysis of direct evidence for SAEM GRACE
Open Access
- 4 November 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Academic Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 32 (1) , 72-86
Abstract
Objectives: Approximately 10% of patients with syncope have serious or life‐threatening causes that may not be apparent during the initial emergency department (ED) assessment. Consequently, researchers have developed clinical decision rules (CDRs) to predict adverse outcomes and risk stratify ED syncope patients. This systematic review and meta‐analysis (SRMA) aims to cohere and synthesize the best current evidence regarding the methodological quality and predictive accuracy of CDRs for developing an evidence‐based ED syncope management guideline.Methods: We conducted a systematic literature search according to the patient–intervention–control–outcome question: In patients 16 years of age or older who present to the ED with syncope for whom no underlying serious/life‐threatening condition was found during the index ED visit (population), are risk stratification tools (intervention), better than unstructured clinical judgment (i.e., usual care; comparison), for providing accurate prognosis and aiding disposition decision for outcomes within 30 days (outcome)? Two reviewers independently assessed articles for inclusion and methodological quality. We performed statistical analysis using Meta‐DiSc. We used GRADEPro GDT software to determine the certainty of the evidence and create a summary of the findings (SoF) tables.Results: Of 2047 publications obtained through the search strategy, 31 comprising 13 CDRs met the inclusion criteria. There were 13 derivation studies (17,578 participants) and 24 validation studies (14,845 participants). Only three CDRs were validated in more than two studies. The San Francisco Syncope Rule (SFSR) was validated in 12 studies: positive likelihood ratio (LR+) 1.15–4.70 and negative likelihood ratio (LR−) 0.03–0.64. The Canadian Syncope Risk Score (CSRS) was validated in five studies: LR+ 1.15–2.58 and LR− 0.05–0.50. The Osservatorio Epidemiologico sulla Sincope nel Lazio (OESIL) risk score was validated in five studies: LR+ 1.16–3.32 and LR− 0.14–0.46.Conclusions: Most CDRs for ED adult syncope management have low‐quality evidence for routine clinical practice use. Only three CDRs (SFSR, CSRS, OESIL) are validated by more than two studies, with significant overlap in operating characteristics.Keywords
Funding Information
- Society for Academic Emergency Medicine
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Physicians’ Perceptions of Clinical Decision Support to Treat Patients With Heart Failure in the EDJAMA Network Open, 2023
- Multicenter Emergency Department Validation of the Canadian Syncope Risk ScoreJAMA Internal Medicine, 2020
- Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions2019
- Simple risk stratification score for prognosis of syncopeJournal of Interventional Cardiac Electrophysiology, 2016
- Emergency department management of syncope: need for standardization and improved risk stratificationInternal and Emergency Medicine, 2015
- San Francisco Syncope Rule, Osservatorio Epidemiologico sulla Sincope nel Lazio risk score, and clinical judgment in the assessment of short-term outcome of syncopeThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2010
- Unconscious ConfusionClinical Autonomic Research, 2005
- Users' Guides to the Medical LiteratureJAMA, 2000
- Clinical Prediction RulesA Review and Suggested Modifications of Methodological StandardsJAMA, 1997
- Evaluation and outcome of emergency room patients with transient loss of consciousnessThe American Journal of Medicine, 1982