Organic amendments (OAs) are widely applied to improve agricultural soil quality, yet their effects on pesticide fate remain difficult to generalize. In particular, it is unclear whether OA-induced changes in sorption translate into corresponding changes in primary degradation. This study investigated pesticide fate across a carbon lability gradient of OAs (molasses, bokashi, compost, biochar), linking OA-driven changes in soil properties to sorption and primary degradation responses across multiple pesticides. Sorption generally increased for most pesticides following bokashi, compost, and biochar OA addition, while molasses addition had weaker and less consistent effects. Sorption responses grouped according to pesticide physicochemical characteristics, particularly hydrophobicity, aromaticity, and ionization. In contrast, primary degradation responses were variable, with both increases, decreases, or no effect observed depending on pesticide and OA type. Across the carbon lability gradient, primary degradation followed a bell-shaped pattern, with intermediate-lability amendments (bokashi and compost) resulting in the most consistent stimulation of pesticide transformation. However, several structurally complex or less biodegradable pesticides showed weak and inconsistent responses regardless of OA type, suggesting that OA addition could not overcome intrinsic degradation limitations. Joint analysis revealed that sorption and degradation were not directly coupled. Similar increases in sorption resulted in divergent degradation trends, indicating that pesticide fate under OA application was a function of bioavailability–degradation balance shaped by OA carbon quality and pesticide-specific properties. These findings highlight the need to consider the interplay between sorption and degradation processes and their controlling factors when assessing pesticide fate in soils receiving OA.