Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Reproducibility Across 3 T Scanners in a Breast Diffusion Phantom

Authors:

Abstract
Background: To date, the accuracy and variability of diffusion‐weighted MRI (DW‐MRI) metrics have been reported in a limited number of scanner/protocol/coil combinations.Purpose: To evaluate the reproducibility of DW‐MRI estimates across multiple scanners and DW‐MRI protocols and to assess the effects of using an 8‐channel vs. 16‐channel breast coil in a breast phantom.Study Type: Prospective.Phantom: Breast phantom containing tubes of water and differing polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) concentrations with apparent diffusion coefficients (ADCs) matching breast tissue.Field Strength/Sequence: 3 T (three standard and one wide bore), three DW‐MRI single‐shot echo planar imaging protocols of varying acquired spatial resolution.Assessment: Accuracy of estimated ADCs was assessed using percent differences (PD) relative to nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy‐derived reference values. Coefficients of variation (CV) were calculated to determine variation across scanners. CVs based on the median standard deviation (CVM) were used to evaluate tube‐specific dispersion using 8‐ or 16‐channel coils at a single scanner. ADCs of PVP‐containing tubes were additionally normalized by the median water tube ADC to account for temperature effects.Statistical Tests: Two‐way repeated measures analysis of variance and post hoc tests were used to evaluate differences in ADC, CV, and CVM across scanners and protocols (α = 0.05).Results: ADCs were within 11% (interquartile range [IQR] 7%) of reference values and significantly improved to 2% (IQR 7%) after normalization to an internal water reference. Normalization significantly reduced interscanner variability of ADC estimates from 7% to 4%. DW‐MRI protocol did not affect ADC accuracy; however, the clinical and higher‐resolution clinical protocols resulted in the greatest (9%) and least (6%) interscanner variability, respectively. The 8‐ and 16‐channel receive coils yielded similar accuracy (PD: 12% vs. 16%) and precision (CVM: 2.7% vs. 2.9%).Data Conclusion: Normalization by an internal reference improved interscanner ADC reproducibility. High‐resolution protocols yielded comparably accurate and significantly less variable ADCs compared to a clinical standard protocol.Evidence Level: 2Technical Efficacy: Stage 1
Funding Information
  • California Breast Cancer Research Program (IDEA Award 25IB‐0056)
  • GE Healthcare
  • National Cancer Institute (R37 CA249659)

This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit: