Active‐Optical Reflectance Sensing Corn Algorithms Evaluated over the United States Midwest Corn Belt
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 November 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Agronomy Journal
- Vol. 110 (6) , 2552-2565
Abstract
Core Ideas: Active‐optical reflectance sensor algorithms perform poorly outside the area for which they were originally developed. The red edge waveband is more sensitive to N stress than the red waveband. Some active‐optical reflectance algorithms are dependent on the sensor for which they were developed. Uncertainty exists with corn (Zea mays L.) N management due to year‐to‐year variation in crop N need, soil N supply, and N loss from leaching, volatilization, and denitrification. Active‐optical reflectance sensing (AORS) has proven effective in some fields for generating N fertilizer recommendations that improve N use efficiency, but locally derived (e.g., within a US state) AORS algorithms have not been tested simultaneously across a broad region. The objective of this research was to evaluate locally developed AORS algorithms across the US Midwest Corn Belt region for making in‐season corn N recommendations. Forty‐nine N response trials were conducted across eight states and three growing seasons. Reflectance measurements were collected and sidedress N rates (45–270 kg N ha−1 on 45 kg ha−1 increments) applied at approximately V9 corn development stage. Nitrogen recommendation rates from AORS algorithms were compared with the end‐of‐season calculated economic optimal N rate (EONR). No algorithm was within 34 kg N ha−1 of EONR > 50% of the time. Average recommendations differed from EONR 81 to 147 kg N ha−1 with no N applied at planting and 74 to 118 kg N ha−1 with 45 kg of N ha−1 at planting, indicating algorithms performed worse with no N applied at planting. With some algorithms, utilizing red edge instead of the red reflectance improved N recommendations. Results demonstrate AORS algorithms developed under a particular set of conditions may not, at least without modification, perform very well in regions outside those within which they were developed.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Generalized Algorithm for Variable‐Rate Nitrogen Application in Cereal GrainsAgronomy Journal, 2012
- Derivation of a Variable Rate Nitrogen Application Model for In‐Season Fertilization of CornAgronomy Journal, 2010
- An Active Sensor Algorithm for Corn Nitrogen Recommendations Based on a Chlorophyll Meter AlgorithmAgronomy Journal, 2010
- Using Active Canopy Sensors to Quantify Corn Nitrogen Stress and Nitrogen Application RateAgronomy Journal, 2010
- Ground‐Based Canopy Reflectance Sensing for Variable‐Rate Nitrogen Corn FertilizationAgronomy Journal, 2010
- Active Sensor Reflectance Measurements of Corn Nitrogen Status and Yield PotentialAgronomy Journal, 2008
- In‐Season Prediction of Corn Grain Yield Potential Using Normalized Difference Vegetation IndexAgronomy Journal, 2006
- Optical Sensor‐Based Algorithm for Crop Nitrogen FertilizationCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 2005
- Field‐Scale Variability in Optimal Nitrogen Fertilizer Rate for CornAgronomy Journal, 2005
- Movement of Nitrate Fertilizer to Glacial Till and Runoff from a Claypan SoilJournal of Environmental Quality, 1996