A Meta-Logical Framework for the Equivalence of Syntactic and Semantic Theories
Open Access
- 27 June 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 10 (4) , 78
Abstract
This paper introduces a meta-logical framework—based on the theory of institutions (a categorical version of abstract model theory)—to be used as a tool for the formalization of the two main views regarding the structure of scientific theories, namely the syntactic and the semantic views, as they have emerged from the relevant contemporary discussion. The formalization leads to a proof of the equivalence of the two views, which supports the claim that the two approaches are not really in tension. The proof is based on the Galois connection between classes of sentences and classes of models defined over some institution. First, the history of the syntactic–semantic debate is recalled and the theory of institutions formally introduced. Secondly, the notions of syntactic and semantic theories are formalized within the institution and their equivalence proved. Finally, the novelty of the proposed framework is highlighted with respect to existing formalizations.Keywords
Funding Information
- Italian Ministry of University and Research (PRIN_20223E8Y4X_002, CUP J53D23019490006)
- National Technical University of Athens (PRIN_20223E8Y4X_002, CUP J53D23019490006)
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- The semantic view of theories and higher-order languagesSynthese, 2017
- One or Two Gentle Remarks about Hans Halvorson’s Critique of the Semantic ViewPhilosophy of Science, 2014
- Generalizing empirical adequacy I: multiplicity and approximationSynthese, 2014
- What’s Right with a Syntactic Approach to Theories and Models?Erkenntnis, 2014
- The Semantic View, If Plausible, Is SyntacticPhilosophy of Science, 2013
- Theoretical Equivalence and the Semantic View of TheoriesPhilosophy of Science, 2013
- What Scientific Theories Could Not BePhilosophy of Science, 2012
- Carnap, Goguen, and the Hyperontologies: Logical Pluralism and Heterogeneous Structuring in Ontology DesignLogica Universalis, 2010
- AN UNREAL IMAGEThe British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 1984
- Adjointness in FoundationsDialectica, 1969