Search or Scroll: How Credibility Versus Likability Premiums Shape Consumer Following Decisions
Open Access
- 24 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Consumer Research
- Vol. 53 (2) , 281-304
Abstract
Consumers’ choices of whom to follow on digital platforms shape their informational landscape. In an era where the credibility of informational sources is critical, this research examines two key questions: (1) When do consumers prioritize communicator credibility over likability in their decisions to follow? and (2) How do multiple credibility and likability cues interact to influence these decisions? Analyzing four large datasets from popular following-enabled platforms, we find consumers’ orientation towards content consumption—goal-directed (“search”) versus experiential (“scroll”)—is key. Communicator credibility drives following on search-driven platforms (Yelp, Goodreads), while likability drives following on scroll-driven ones (Twitter/X, Instagram). Aggregate communicator sentiment across multiple posts serves as a cross-platform indicator of credibility and likability, and its effect on follower-count differs by platform type. On scroll-driven platforms, communicators with positive aggregate sentiment benefit from a likeability premium, attracting the most followers; this preference for positivity is mitigated by the presence of alternative communicator likeability cues (e.g., using sociable language). On search-driven platforms, communicators with mixed aggregate sentiment benefit from a credibility premium, attracting the most followers; this preference for mixed sentiment is mitigated in the presence of alternative credibility cues (e.g., Yelp’s “Elite” badge). Implications for consumer protection and platform design are discussed.Keywords
Funding Information
- Open University of Israel’s Research Fund (514249)
- Israel Science Foundation (1421/22)
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- Social Media Posts About Medical Tests With Potential for OverdiagnosisJAMA Network Open, 2025
- Untangling the web of misinformation and false beliefsJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2022
- Online influencer marketingJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2022
- Persuasion Knowledge in the Marketplace: A Meta‐AnalysisJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2021
- Habits and the electronic herd: The psychology behind social media’s successes and failuresConsumer Psychology Review, 2020
- An Appeal to Intimacy: Consumer Response to Platform‐Appeal Fit on Social MediaJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2019
- Conceptualizing the electronic word-of-mouth process: What we know and need to know about eWOM creation, exposure, and evaluationJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2019
- How online word‐of‐mouth impacts receiversConsumer Psychology Review, 2019
- Real Solutions for Fake News? Measuring the Effectiveness of General Warnings and Fact-Check Tags in Reducing Belief in False Stories on Social MediaPolitical Behavior, 2019
- The relationship between trusting beliefs and Web site loyalty: The moderating role of consumer motives and flowPsychology & Marketing, 2010