Underpinning current writings on human rights, one can discern a tone of urgency if not high anxiety. Authors are expressing bluntly their fear that populist agendas that are “avowedly nationalistic, xenophobic, misogynistic, and explicitly antagonistic to all or much of the human rights agenda” have become the dominant political force around the world and that “there is a revolt afoot against a global, cosmopolitan, liberal consensus” (Alston 2017). A strong variant of this theme has been expressed by Stephen Hopgood (2013) who begins his book “The Endtimes of Human Rights” with the claim that “the prospect of one world under a secular human rights law is receding. What seemed like a dawn is in fact a sunset. The foundations of universal liberal norms and global governance are crumbling, creating a vacancy where sovereignty and religion now make dramatic inroads in the post-Cold War World.” In the following pages, building on claims by Hollifield and Joppke that domestic courts, rather than the International Human Rights Regime have served and can continue to serve as a powerful control over excessive claims of sovereignty, I suggest that it is timely to reconsider and re-imagine how this assault against human rights can be addressed in the courtroom. I present immigration law, refugee law and citizenship law as fields in which the deficiencies of nativism and populism can be readily exposed. While the Supreme Court of Canada and the Federal Courts have hesitated in recent years to extend a constitutional cloak of protection to non-citizens, the spectre of an illiberal future and reframed arguments may be sufficient to persuade them to alter their stance.