Reliability of intraoperative high-resolution 2D ultrasound as an alternative to high–field strength MR imaging for tumor resection control: a prospective comparative study
Authors:
- Venelin Miloslavov GerganovVGVenelin Miloslavov Gerganov
- Amir SamiiASAmir Samii
- Arasch AkbarianAAArasch Akbarian
- Lennart StieglitzLSLennart Stieglitz
- Madjid SamiiMSMadjid Samii
- Rudolf FahlbuschRFRudolf Fahlbusch
- 1 September 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Journal of Neurosurgery Publishing Group (JNSPG) in Journal of Neurosurgery
- Vol. 111 (3) , 512-519
Abstract
Object: Ultrasound may be a reliable but simpler alternative to intraoperative MR imaging (iMR imaging) for tumor resection control. However, its reliability in the detection of tumor remnants has not been definitely proven. The aim of the study was to compare high-field iMR imaging (1.5 T) and high-resolution 2D ultrasound in terms of tumor resection control. Methods: A prospective comparative study of 26 consecutive patients was performed. The following parameters were compared: the existence of tumor remnants after presumed radical removal and the quality of the images. Tumor remnants were categorized as: detectable with both imaging modalities or visible only with 1 modality. Results: Tumor remnants were detected in 21 cases (80.8%) with iMR imaging. All large remnants were demonstrated with both modalities, and their image quality was good. Two-dimensional ultrasound was not as effective in detecting remnants < 1 cm. Two remnants detected with iMR imaging were missed by ultrasound. In 2 cases suspicious signals visible only on ultrasound images were misinterpreted as remnants but turned out to be a blood clot and peritumoral parenchyma. The average time for acquisition of an ultrasound image was 2 minutes, whereas that for an iMR image was ~ 10 minutes. Neither modality resulted in any procedure-related complications or morbidity. Conclusions: Intraoperative MR imaging is more precise in detecting small tumor remnants than 2D ultrasound. Nevertheless, the latter may be used as a less expensive and less time-consuming alternative that provides almost real-time feedback information. Its accuracy is highest in case of more confined, deeply located remnants. In cases of more superficially located remnants, its role is more limited.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Intraoperative ultrasound in determining the extent of resection of parenchymal brain tumours ? a comparative study with computed tomography and histopathologyActa Neurochirurgica, 2003
- Intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging during transsphenoidal surgeryJournal of Neurosurgery, 2001
- SonoWand, an Ultrasound-based Neuronavigation SystemNeurosurgery, 2000
- Use of intraoperative ultrasound for localizing tumors and determining the extent of resection: a comparative study with magnetic resonance imagingJournal of Neurosurgery, 1996
- High-grade Astrocytomas in Children: Radiologically Complete Resection Is Associated with an Excellent Long-term PrognosisNeurosurgery, 1996
- The effect of extent of resection on recurrence in patients with low grade cerebral hemisphere gliomasCancer, 1994
- Early Postoperative Magnetic Resonance Imaging after Resection of Malignant Glioma: Objective Evaluation of Residual Tumor and Its Influence on Regrowth and PrognosisNeurosurgery, 1994
- Intraoperative ultrasound (US) imaging. Comparison of pathomorphological findings in US and CTActa Neurochirurgica, 1990
- Intraoperative Ultraschall-Bildgebung in der Neurochirurgie*Ultraschall in der Medizin - European Journal of Ultrasound, 1990
- Intraoperative use of real-time ultrasonography in neurosurgeryJournal of Neurosurgery, 1982