Reframing hunting: A transdisciplinary framework integrating ecological, social and historical dimensions
Preprint
- 17 February 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
SSustainability assessments of hunting often emphasize ecological impacts while overlooking the social and historical processes that shape human–wildlife interactions, constraining understanding of hunting as a socio-ecological phenomenon. We address this gap using an ethnographically-led transdisciplinary framework in a non-Indigenous rural territory of the Argentine Dry Chaco. We combined camera trapping, semi-structured interviews, and participatory workshops to examine interconnected ecological, social, and historical dimensions. Specifically, we aim to: (i) assess medium- and large-mammal (MLM) assemblages, (ii) document local hunting patterns and social norms, and (iii) reconstruct historical socio-ecological dynamics and wildlife population trends. All 19 MLM species expected for the area were recorded, including several threatened taxa. Contemporary hunting is cyclical and selective, focusing primarily on resilient medium-bodied species. Combined with sporadic outings, low human population density, and limited modernization of hunting technologies, these conditions result in low-intensity hunting. Social norms play a central role in shaping hunting patterns and wildlife composition by regulating hunting practices and defining their social legitimacy. The historical dimension revealed that hunting was substantially more intensive during the obrajes period, when international fur markets drove commercial extraction; these pressures have since declined and hunting is no longer commercially motivated. Integrating ecological, social, and historical dimensions demonstrates that present wildlife assemblages in this non-Indigenous rural territory remain well represented despite ongoing hunting. Our findings show that hunting impacts are contingent on motivations, social regulation, and historical legacies, revealing the limitations of generalized sustainability assessments and the value of situated transdisciplinary, mixed-method approaches for conservation.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Predicting animal abundance through local ecological knowledge: An internal validation using consensus analysisPeople and Nature, 2024
- Less than six generations to save the chacoan peccaryBiodiversity and Conservation, 2022
- Deconstructing Hunting Returns: Can We Reconstruct and Predict Payoffs from Pursuing Prey?Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory, 2021
- Importance of Indigenous Peoples’ lands for the conservation of Intact Forest LandscapesFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2020
- Approaching human-animal relationships from multiple angles: A synthetic perspectiveBiological Conservation, 2018
- The evidence for the bushmeat crisis in African savannas: A systematic quantitative literature reviewBiological Conservation, 2018
- Animals as Ethnozooindicators of Weather and Climate2018
- Who hunts lemurs and why they hunt themBiological Conservation, 2016
- Connecting Diverse Knowledge Systems for Enhanced Ecosystem Governance: The Multiple Evidence Base ApproachAMBIO, 2014
- Hunting reduces recruitment of primate-dispersed trees in Amazonian PeruBiological Conservation, 2008