The prevalence of incivility in hospitals and the effects of incivility on patient safety culture and outcomes: A systematic review and meta‐analysis
Authors:
- Benjamin FreedmanBFBenjamin Freedman
- Benjamin FreedmanBFBenjamin Freedman
- Wendy Wen LiWLWendy Wen Li
- Wendy Wen LiWLWendy Wen Li
- Zhanming LiangZLZhanming Liang
- Zhanming LiangZLZhanming Liang
- Peter HartinPHPeter Hartin
- Peter HartinPHPeter Hartin
- Narelle BiedermannNBNarelle Biedermann
- Narelle BiedermannNBNarelle Biedermann
Open Access
- 21 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 81 (9) , 5603-5622
Abstract
Aim: Workplace incivility is a barrier to safe and high‐quality patient care in nursing workplaces and more broadly in tertiary hospitals. The present study aims to systematically review the existing evidence to provide a comprehensive understanding of the prevalence of co‐worker incivility experienced and witnessed by nurses and other healthcare professionals, the effects of incivility on patient safety culture (PSC) and patient outcomes, and the factors which mediate the relationship between incivility and patient safety. Methods: A systematic review with narrative synthesis and meta‐analysis was undertaken to synthesize the data from 41 studies. Data Sources: Databases searched included MEDLINE, PubMed, SCOPUS, CINAHL, PsycInfo, ProQuest, Emcare and Embase. Searches were conducted on 17 August 2021 and repeated on 15 March 2023. Results: The pooled prevalence of experienced incivility was 25.0%. The pooled prevalence of witnessed incivility was 30.1%. Workplace incivility was negatively associated with the PSC domains of teamwork, reporting patient safety events, organization learning/improvement, management support for safety, leadership, communication openness and communication about error. The composite pooled effect size of incivility on these domains of PSC was OR = 0.590, 95% CI [0.515, 0.676]. Workplace incivility was associated with a range of patient safety outcomes (PSOs) including near misses, adverse events, reduced procedural and diagnostic performance, medical error and mortality. State depletion, profession, psychological responses to incivility, information sharing, help seeking, workload and satisfaction with organizational communication were found to mediate the relationship between incivility and patient safety. Conclusion: Experienced and witnessed incivility is prevalent in tertiary hospitals and has a deleterious effect on PSC and PSOs. A better understanding of the mechanisms of this relationship will support the development of interventions aimed at reducing both incivility and patient harm. Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care Impact: This study quantifies the effect of incivility on PSC and outcomes. It provides support that interventions focusing on incivility are a valuable mechanism for improving patient care. It guides intervention design by highlighting which domains of PSC are most associated with incivility. It explores the profession‐specific experiences of workplace incivility. Reporting Method: This report adheres to PRISMA reporting guidelines. Patient or Public Contribution: No patient or public contribution. The focus of this study is the nursing and healthcare workforce, therefore, patient or public involvement not required.Keywords
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- A systematic review and meta-analysis on adverse childhood experiences: Prevalence in youth offenders and their effects on youth recidivismChild Abuse & Neglect, 2023
- Exposure to incivility does not hinder speaking up: a randomised controlled high-fidelity simulation-based studyBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2022
- Effect of nurses’ perception to workplace civility climate on nurse–physician collaborationNursing Open, 2020
- Effects of hospital nurses' internalized dominant values, organizational silence, horizontal violence, and organizational communication on patient safetyResearch in Nursing & Health, 2020
- Association of Coworker Reports About Unprofessional Behavior by Surgeons With Surgical Complications in Their PatientsJAMA Surgery, 2019
- Incivility and Patient Safety: A Longitudinal Study of Rudeness, Protocol Compliance, and Adverse EventsThe Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety, 2019
- Effects of disruptive surgeon behavior in the operating roomThe American Journal of Surgery, 2015
- Incidence and Impact of Physician and Nurse Disruptive Behaviors in the Emergency DepartmentThe Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2012
- Disruptive behavior in obstetrics: a hidden threat to patient safetyAmerican Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2007
- Impact and Implications of Disruptive Behavior in the Perioperative ArenaJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2006