What are the methodological characteristics of evidence and gap maps? A systematic review and evidence and gap map
Authors:
Open Access
- 5 August 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Cochrane Evidence Synthesis and Methods
- Vol. 2 (8) , e12096
Abstract
Introduction: Clarity on the characteristics of methods used to produce evidence and gap maps (EGMs) will highlight areas where method development is needed to ensure these increasingly produced tools are made following best practice to assure their quality and utility. This paper aims to describe the range, nature and variability of key methodological characteristics of studies publishing EGMs.Methods: We followed a protocol, written a‐prior and informed by PRISMA and MECCIR guidelines for undertaking systematic reviews. We searched nine data bases, from 2010, for studies across any discipline that included details of their methods used to produce an EGM. Search results were screened by two reviewers independently and the subsequent data was extracted and managed according to predefined criteria. We mapped these together with the year of publication and the area of research as the two primary dimensions. We followed established methods for mapping the evidence, including the process of developing the map framework and the filters for our interactive map. We sought input and involvement from stakeholders during this process.Results: We found 145 studies from nine distinct research areas, with health research accounting for 67%. There were 11 map designs found, of these bubble plots were the most common design, before 2019, since then it has been a matrix map design. Stakeholders were involved in 47.7% of studies, 48.35% of studies stated finding gaps was an aim of their work, 42% reported publishing or registering a protocol and only 9.39% of studies mentioned a plan to update their evidence maps/EGMs.Discussion/Conclusion: Key areas of methodological development relate to: the involvement of stakeholders, the conceptualization of gaps and the practices for updating maps. The issues of ambiguity in terminology, the flexibility of visualizations of the data and the lack of reporting detail were other aspects that needs further consideration in studies producing an EGM.Keywords
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dietary interventions and nutritional supplements for heart failure: a systematic appraisal and evidence mapEuropean Journal of Heart Failure, 2021
- What is the evidence documenting the effects of marine or coastal nature conservation or natural resource management activities on human well-being in South East Asia? A systematic mapEnvironment International, 2021
- Interventions that address institutional child maltreatment: An evidence and gap mapCampbell Systematic Reviews, 2021
- Guidance for producing a Campbell evidence and gap mapCampbell Systematic Reviews, 2020
- Mega-map of systematic reviews and evidence and gap maps on the interventions to improve child well-being in low- and middle-income countriesCampbell Systematic Reviews, 2020
- Interventions for reducing violence against children in low- and middle-income countries: An evidence and gap mapCampbell Systematic Reviews, 2020
- Application of systematic evidence mapping to assess the impact of new research when updating health reference values: A case example using acroleinEnvironment International, 2020
- Evidence and gap map of studies assessing the effectiveness of interventions for people with disabilities in low-and middle-income countriesCampbell Systematic Reviews, 2020
- Evidence & Gap Maps: A tool for promoting evidence informed policy and strategic research agendasJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2016
- Childhood Obesity Policy Research and PracticeAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2014