Developing and using a School Menu Healthiness Assessment Tool to analyse school food provision in Wales
Open Access
- 10 January 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Public Health Nutrition
- Vol. 28 (1) , 1-20
Abstract
Objectives: To design and develop a new, innovative and valid School Menu Healthiness Assessment Tool that is suitable for the quantitative and qualitative analysis of school food and drink provision. Second, to analyse primary and secondary school menus and price lists pan-Wales to ascertain their healthiness and whether free school meal (FSM) eligible pupils can afford to access healthy, nutritious food across the school day. Design: Codable items and categories of school food and drink provision were operationalised before the tool underwent iterative development and testing. Then, cross-sectional content analysis of publicly available documents detailing school food provision (i.e. menus and price lists) was done. Setting: Primary and secondary schools in Wales, UK. Participants: In total, 82 canteen menus were sourced online. This comprised local authority catering for primary (n 22) and secondary (n 19) schools and school-organised catering for primary (n 5) and secondary (n 36) schools. Results: Intercoder reliability testing found high agreeability between coders, demonstrating that the tool and data interpretation are reproducible and trustworthy. The FSM allowance is not wholly sufficient for all secondary school pupils to purchase a healthy meal from the school canteen. Moreover, the tool identified that oily fish and wholegrain provision were lacking across many menus. Conclusions: A valuable tool was created, useful for researchers and other health professionals (i.e. dietitians) who are required to analyse the healthiness of school food provision in line with the latest nutritional requirements. This study provides insight into the current school food and drink landscape pan-Wales.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- A content and thematic analysis of Welsh school food menu design and healthiness compared to present government guidelinesProceedings of the Nutrition Society, 2024
- School food hero and the battle of the food foes: A story of public health policy, power imbalance and potentialSocial Science & Medicine, 2023
- Dietary quality of school meals and packed lunches: a national study of primary and secondary schoolchildren in the UKPublic Health Nutrition, 2022
- School meals as a resource for low-income families in three European countries: a comparative case approachEuropean Societies, 2022
- What works to improve school lunch nutritional quality – legislation or self-audit?Public Health Nutrition, 2022
- An approach for selecting and using a method of inter-coder reliability in information management researchInternational Journal of Information Management, 2020
- Objective assessment of compliance with a state-wide school food-service policy via menu auditsPublic Health Nutrition, 2019
- Key Characteristics of Public Health Interventions Aimed at Increasing Whole Grain Intake: A Systematic ReviewJournal of Nutrition Education and Behavior, 2018
- Meeting school food standards – students’ food choice and free school mealsPublic Health Nutrition, 2013
- Content Analysis: Review of Methods and Their Applications in Nutrition EducationJournal of Nutrition Education and Behavior, 2002