Population aging increases pressure on pay-as-you-go pension systems and shifts responsibility for retirement income toward individuals. Yet little is known about how consumers value key attributes of decumulation products and whether these preferences align with financial trade-offs and policy objectives. We study decumulation as a multistakeholder coordination problem involving consumers, financial service providers, and policy makers. Using a choice-based conjoint experiment calibrated with Monte Carlo simulations of realistic drawdown strategies, we quantify how individuals trade off monthly consumption, risk of running out of wealth, consumption volatility, and endof-horizon wealth. We document three main findings. First, end-of-horizon wealth is the dominant attribute, while the risk of running out and consumption volatility receive lower importance weights. Second, consumers' willingness-to-pay for end-ofhorizon wealth exceeds market-consistent trade-offs, indicating positive surplus potential that providers can exploit through capital-market-based products. A latent segmentation reveals two consumer types, Wealth Preservers and Balanced Decumulators, that are indistinguishable by demographics but require fundamentally different product and communication strategies. Third, retirement experience increases the salience of wealth preservation in ways that workers without retirement experience fail to anticipate. Overall, our results suggest that coordination and product design, rather than fundamental conflicts of interest, constitute the primary bottleneck in decumulation markets.