Quality of reporting of randomized clinical trials in implant dentistry. A systematic review on critical aspects in design, outcome assessment and clinical relevance
Authors:
- 1 February 2012
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Periodontology
- Vol. 39 (s12) , 81-107
Abstract
Background: The aim of this systematic review (SR) was to assess the quality of reporting randomized clinical trials (RCTs) in the field of implant dentistry, its evolution over time and the possible relations between quality items and reported outcomes.Material and Methods: RCTs in implant dentistry were retrieved through electronic and hand searches. Risk of bias in individual studies was assessed focusing on study design, outcome assessment and clinical relevance. Associations between quality items and year of publication of RCTs or reporting of statistically significant outcomes were tested.Results: Among the 495 originally screened manuscripts published from 1989 to April 2011, 276 RCTs were assessed in this SR; 59% of them were published between 2006 and 2011. RCTs were mainly parallel (65%), with a single centre (83%) and a superiority design (88%). Trials in implant dentistry showed several methodological flaws: only 37% showed a random sequence generation at low risk of bias, 75% did not provide information on allocation concealment, only 12% performed a correct sample size calculation, the examiner was blind solely in 42% of studies where blinding was feasible. In addition, only 21% of RCTs declared operator experience and 31% reported patient‐related outcomes. Many quality items improved over time. Allocation concealment at high risk of bias (p = 0.0125), no information on drop‐out (p = 0.0318) and lack of CONSORT adherence (p = 0.0333) were associated with statistically significant reported outcomes.Conclusions: The overall quality of reporting of RCTs in implant dentistry is poor and only partially improved in the last years. Caution is suggested when interpreting these RCTs since risk of bias was associated with higher chance of reporting of statistically significant results.Keywords
This publication has 362 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evolution of reports of randomised clinical trials in plastic surgeryJournal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, 2011
- Better oral health related quality of life: Type of prosthesis or psychological robustness?Journal of Dentistry, 2010
- Comparison of Registered and Published Primary Outcomes in Randomized Controlled TrialsJAMA, 2009
- Comparison of procedures for immediate reconstruction of large osseous defects resulting from removal of a single tooth to prepare for insertion of an endosseous implant after healingInternational Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2009
- Sex differences in denture satisfactionJournal of Dentistry, 2008
- Alveolar distraction osteogenesis versus inlay bone grafting in posterior mandibular atrophy: a prospective studyOral Surgery Oral Medicine Oral Pathology Oral Radiology and Endodontology, 2008
- Can general dentists produce successful implant overdentures with minimal training?Journal of Dentistry, 2006
- Reporting of Noninferiority and Equivalence Randomized TrialsJAMA, 2006
- The impact of conventional and implant supported prostheses on social and sexual activities in edentulous adultsJournal of Dentistry, 2005
- Patient satisfaction with implant-retained mandibular overdentures. A comparison with new complete dentures not retained by implants— a multicentre randomized clinical trialBritish Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 1995