Analytical Pluralism in Qualitative Research: A Meta-Study
Authors:
- Nicola J. ClarkeNCNicola J. Clarke
- Martin E. H. WillisMWMartin E. H. Willis
- Jemima S. BarnesJBJemima S. Barnes
- Nick CaddickNCNick Caddick
- John CrombyJCJohn Cromby
- Hilary McDermottHMHilary McDermott
- Gareth WiltshireGWGareth Wiltshire
Open Access
- 19 August 2014
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Qualitative Research in Psychology
- Vol. 12 (2) , 182-201
Abstract
This article is closed access.Recent interest in analytical pluralism—the application of more than one qualitative analytical method to a single data set—has demonstrated its potential to produce multiple, complex, and varied understandings of phenomena. However, tensions remain regarding the commensurability of findings produced from diverse theoretical frameworks, the practical application of multiple methods of analysis, and the capacity of pluralism to contribute to knowledge in psychology. This study addresses these issues through a critical interpretation of existing qualitative studies that utilized analytical pluralism. Using a meta-study design, we examined the use of theory, application of methods, and production of findings in studies that had adopted qualitative analytical pluralism. Following comprehensive database searches, ten articles were included in the analysis. Epistemological and ontological considerations, the influence of decisions made in the practical application of pluralism, and approaches to interpreting findings produced from multiple analyses are discussed, and implications for future research are consideredKeywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pluralisms in Qualitative Research: From Multiple Methods to Integrated MethodsQualitative Research in Psychology, 2011
- Exploring and Expanding on Pluralism in Qualitative Research in PsychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2011
- Collective Findings, Individual Interpretations: An Illustration of a Pluralistic Approach to Qualitative Data AnalysisQualitative Research in Psychology, 2011
- Troubling methodologyHealth Psychology Review, 2011
- Investigating the Form and Dynamics of Crisis Episodes in Early Adulthood: The Application of a Composite Qualitative MethodQualitative Research in Psychology, 2010
- Qualitative Research and Anomalous Experience: A Call for Interpretative PluralismQualitative Research in Psychology, 2010
- Social Psychology and the Empirical Body: Rethinking the RelationshipSocial and Personality Psychology Compass, 2010
- `Do you know what I mean?': the use of a pluralistic narrative analysis approach in the interpretation of an interviewQualitative Research, 2009
- “Can't Really Trust That, So What Can I Trust?”: A Polyvocal, Qualitative Analysis of the Psychology of MistrustQualitative Research in Psychology, 2008
- Shifting the Focus: Sequential Methods of Analysis With Qualitative DataQualitative Health Research, 2008