Misaccounting for endogeneity: The peril of relying on the Heckman two‐step method without a valid instrument
Top Cited Papers
- 21 December 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 40 (3) , 432-462
Abstract
Research Summary: Strategy research addresses endogeneity by incorporating econometric techniques, including Heckman's two‐step method. The economics literature theorizes regarding optimal usage of Heckman's method, emphasizing the valid exclusion condition necessary in the first stage. However, our meta‐analysis reveals that only 54 of 165 relevant papers published in the top strategy and organizational theory journals during 1995–2016 claim a valid exclusion restriction. Without this condition being met, our simulation shows that results using the Heckman method are often less reliable than OLS results. Even where Heckman is not possible, we recommend that other rigorous identification approaches be used. We illustrate our recommendation to use a triangulation of identification approaches by revisiting the classic global strategy question of the performance implications of cross‐border market entry through greenfield or acquisition. Managerial Summary: Managers make strategic decisions by choosing the best option given the particular circumstances of their firm. However, researchers had previously not taken into consideration these circumstances when evaluating the outcome of that choice. The Heckman method importantly addresses this situation, but requires that the researcher have some variable that effects the best option for the firm, but not the outcome. We show that researchers frequently do not utilize such a variable, and demonstrate that the Heckman method can exacerbate estimation issues in this case. We then provide an approach that researchers can use to address the challenge of determining the outcome of a strategic decision, and illustrate it with an empirical examination of the performance implications of cross‐border market entry through greenfield or acquisition.Keywords
Funding Information
- Cornell University Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management
- University of Michigan Ross School of Business
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Selection bias and the Big Four premium: New evidence using Heckman and matching modelsAccounting and Business Research, 2009
- Controlling for endogeneity with instrumental variables in strategic management researchStrategic Organization, 2008
- Contingent Political Capital and International Alliances: Evidence from South KoreaAdministrative Science Quarterly, 2007
- Instrumental Variables and the Search for Identification: From Supply and Demand to Natural ExperimentsJournal of Economic Perspectives, 2001
- The Heckman Correction for Sample Selection and Its CritiqueJournal of Economic Surveys, 2000
- A Monte Carlo Analysis of Alternative Estimators in Models Involving SelectivityJournal of Business & Economic Statistics, 1991
- The Effect of National Culture on the Choice of Entry ModeJournal of International Business Studies, 1988
- Statistics and Causal InferenceJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1986
- Dummy Endogenous Variables in a Simultaneous Equation SystemEconometrica, 1978
- TESTING FOR NORMALITYBiometrika, 1947