Comparison of Broth Disk Elution and Broth Microdilution Methods for Colistin Susceptibility Testing in Carbapenem-Resistant Enterobacteriaceae and Pseudomonas aeruginosa
Authors:
- Rajesh P. KaryakarteRKRajesh P. Karyakarte
- Priyanka M. Chandankhede Sr.PSPriyanka M. Chandankhede Sr.
Open Access
- 8 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Cureus
- Vol. 17 (9)
Abstract
Background: The increasing prevalence of carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae (CRE) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (CRPA) poses a significant challenge to clinical management, particularly in resource-limited settings. Colistin remains one of the last-resort antibiotics for treating these infections; however, its accurate susceptibility testing remains technically challenging. The Broth Microdilution (BMD) method, though recommended as the reference standard, is labor-intensive and not feasible for routine use in most laboratories. This study aims to evaluate the Colistin Broth Disk Elution (CBDE) method as a practical alternative to BMD. Materials and methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted over 18 months (December 2022 to June 2024) at a tertiary care microbiology laboratory in India. A total of 120 non-duplicate CRE and CRPA isolates from clinical specimens were randomly selected and tested for colistin susceptibility using both BMD and CBDE methods. MIC interpretations were based on CLSI 2024 guidelines. Categorical agreement (CA), essential agreement (EA), and error rates were analyzed as per CLSI 2015 recommendations. Results: Out of 120 carbapenem-resistant isolates included in the study, 92 (76.67%) were CRE and 28 (23.33%) were CRPA. Colistin resistance was detected in six (5%) and four (3.33%) isolates by BMD and CBDE, respectively. CBDE showed a CA of 98.3% (95% confidence Interval: 94.1%-99.8%) and EA of 100% when compared to BMD, with only two minor errors (1.6%) and no major or very major errors. Conclusion: CBDE demonstrated high categorical agreement with BMD and minimal error and offers a simple, cost-effective alternative for routine colistin susceptibility testing, especially in low-resource settings where BMD is not feasible.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Phenotypic Detection of Carbapenemase Production in Gram Negative Bacilli from Clinical Isolates in a Tertiary Care Hospital in TelanganaJournal of Pure and Applied Microbiology, 2023
- Evaluation of Colistin Broth Disk Elution and Colistin Agar Test: A study from Tertiary Care Hospital, South IndiaJournal of Pure and Applied Microbiology, 2022
- Detection of Colistin Resistance in Carbapenem Resistant Enterobacteriaceae by Reference Broth Microdilution and Comparative Evaluation of Three Other MethodsJournal of Laboratory Physicians, 2021
- Clinical, phenotypic and genotypic profile of carbapenem resistant gram negative infections in intensive care unitsIndian Journal of Microbiology Research, 2021
- A Study on Burden of Carbapenem-Resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Acinetobacter baumannii Infections in a Tertiary Care Hospital of Eastern IndiaInternational Journal of Contemporary Medical Research [IJCMR], 2019
- Multicenter Evaluation of Colistin Broth Disk Elution and Colistin Agar Test: a Report from the Clinical and Laboratory Standards InstituteJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2019
- Two-Site Evaluation of the Colistin Broth Disk Elution Test To Determine Colistin In Vitro Activity against Gram-Negative BacilliJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2019
- Detection of carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae by chromogenic screening mediaJournal of Microbiological Methods, 2018
- CLSI Methods Development and Standardization Working Group Best Practices for Evaluation of Antimicrobial Susceptibility TestsJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2018
- A Study on Phenotypic Characterization of Carbapenemases among Gram Negative Bacilli in a Tertiary Care HospitalJournal of Medical Science And clinical Research, 2016