Comparison of the use of new handheld tonometers and established applanation tonometers in dogs
Authors:
- Roel T. I. CoenenRCRoel T. I. Coenen
- Frans C. StadesFSFrans C. Stades
- Sylvia C. Djajadiningrat-LaanenSDSylvia C. Djajadiningrat-Laanen
- Michael H. BoevéMBMichael H. Boevé
- 1 January 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) in American Journal of Veterinary Research
- Vol. 67 (1) , 134-144
Abstract
Objective—To examine the practical aspects, accuracy, and reproducibility of 2 new automatic handheld tonometers in dogs and compare them with results for 2 established applanation tonometers. Animals—15 freshly enucleated canine eyes for manometric evaluation and 20 conscious research dogs, 20 client-owned dogs, and 12 dogs with acute glaucoma for clinical tonometry. Procedure—Calibration curves were determined for all 4 tonometers on 15 enucleated canine eyes. Intraocular pressure (IOP) was measured with each tonometer consecutively in conscious dogs, with the MacKay-Marg applanation tonometer as the reference device. Measurements were repeated in 20 sedated dogs. An induction-impact tonometer was evaluated clinically on dogs with acute glaucoma. Additionally, measurements obtained by an experienced and an inexperienced examiner and with or without use of topical anesthesia were compared. Results—The portable pneumatonometer was cumbersome and time-consuming. Compared with results for the reference applanation tonometer, and confirmed by manometry, the portable pneumatonometer increasingly underestimated actual IOP values with increasing IOP. The induction-impact tonometer provided accurate and reproducible measurement values. There was a significant strong correlation between the IOP values obtained by the 2 examiners (r2, 0.82) and also with or without topical anesthesia (r2, 0.86). In dogs with glaucoma, the fitted line comparing values for the reference applanation tonometer and induction-impact tonometer closely resembled an ideal 1:1 relationship. Conclusions and Clinical Relevance—Use of the portable pneumatonometer in dogs appears to have disadvantages. The induction-impact tonometer appears to provide a promising alternative to the use of applanation tonometers in dogs.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tono‐Pen XL®calibration curves for cats, cows and sheepVeterinary Ophthalmology, 2004
- The Induction/Impact Tonometer: a New Instrument to Measure Intraocular Pressure in the RatExperimental Eye Research, 2001
- Evaluation of intraocular pressure in eyes of clinically normal llamas and alpacasAmerican Journal of Veterinary Research, 2000
- A new induction‐based impact method for measuring intraocular pressureActa Ophthalmologica Scandinavica, 2000
- Influence of Topical Anesthesia on Tonometric Values of Intraocular PressureOphthalmologica, 1994
- Reproduzierbarkeit der Meßwerte zweier Non-Contact-Tonometer - Vergleich mit dem Goldmann-ApplanationstonometerKlinische Monatsblätter für Augenheilkunde, 1992
- The Effect of Perkins, Tono-Pen, and Schiötz Tonometry on Intraocular PressureAmerican Journal of Ophthalmology, 1991
- Evaluation of the Tono-Pen and the Pulsair TonometersAmerican Journal of Ophthalmology, 1990
- The Tono-PenArchives of Ophthalmology (1950), 1988
- Calibration of the Alcon applanation pneumatonograph and Perkins tonometer for use in rabbits and catsCurrent Eye Research, 1984