Harnessing knowledge: A multi-taxa evaluation of device attachment elements, reporting gaps, and protocols for best practices in wild birds
Authors:
- Amy L ScarpignatoASAmy L Scarpignato
- Calandra Q StanleyCSCalandra Q Stanley
- Alexandra M AndersonAAAlexandra M Anderson
- Nathan W CooperNCNathan W Cooper
- Autumn-Lynn HarrisonAHAutumn-Lynn Harrison
- Valentine HerrmannVHValentine Herrmann
- Fernando G LópezFLFernando G López
- María E RebolloMRMaría E Rebollo
- Kristina M DelaskiKDKristina M Delaski
- Peter P MarraPMPeter P Marra
- 8 May 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Ornithology
Abstract
The increased use of bio-logging devices for studies in avian ecology has outpaced the evaluation of device attachment and development of reporting guidelines and protocols that protect animal welfare and data quality. To address this gap, we report on external attachment methods across multiple taxa and define 3 elements, the design, materials, and procedure, that provide a framework to approach device attachment. We conducted a narrative literature review (2010–2022; n = 1,160 studies) and survey of the ornithological community (2020; n = 167 respondents) to assess the use of attachment methods and the reporting of methods and impacts. Harness and mount attachments were used almost equally across the literature and survey. However, 14% of reviewed studies did not report any attachment type and nearly a third lacked sufficient detail to categorize the harness design used. Harness types varied by taxonomic order, with leg-loop and backpack harnesses being the most prevalent and the focus of further analysis. The number of devices deployed was frequently reported in published papers; details on harness and securing material and size were less commonly provided. One fifth of reviewed papers (n = 269) using backpack or leg-loop harnesses reported on impacts of attachments, and of those, 58% indicated neutral impacts. By contrast, only 23% of survey respondents reported not encountering impacts in their research. The survey also provided methodological details not found in the literature review, suggesting this knowledge exists outside of the published literature. We emphasize the need for standardized reporting of device attachment methodologies and their impacts on birds. Accordingly, we introduce two illustrated protocols for device attachment. We encourage adaptation for different species and study conditions to support consistency, reproducibility, and ethical, efficient practices ensuring bio-logging remains a key tool for avian research and conservation. Bio-logging has become a standard research tool for studying bird movements and revealing information about demographic rates. As such, there is a need to better evaluate bio-logging methodology, with the goal of minimizing impacts to birds while maximizing data quality. We conducted a literature review and survey to assess methods used to attach bio-logging devices to wild birds and evaluate reporting of methods and impacts. Harnesses, particularly leg-loop and backpack, were commonly used attachment methods, but their use varied across different bird groups. Although the number of devices deployed was frequently reported, details on harness and securing material and size, and impacts were less commonly provided. The survey suggested much knowledge exists outside of the published literature and when not shared with the broader community, limits refinement and reproducibility of methods. Our findings emphasize the need for standardization of attachment methods and reporting. Accordingly, we introduce two illustrated protocols for researchers.Keywords
Funding Information
- ConocoPhillips Charitable Investments Global Signature
- the Knobloch Family Foundation
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Power source, data retrieval method, and attachment type affect success of dorsally mounted tracking tag deployments in 37 species of shorebirdsJournal of Avian Biology, 2025
- Establishing bio-logging data collections as dynamic archives of animal life on EarthNature Ecology & Evolution, 2025
- Tracking individual animals can reveal the mechanisms of species lossTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2024
- Shortfalls in tracking data available to inform North American migratory bird conservationBiological Conservation, 2023
- New frontiers in bird migration researchCurrent Biology, 2022
- Testing an attachment method for solar-powered tracking devices on a long-distance migrating shorebirdJournal of Ornithology, 2015
- Tracking devices attached with harnesses influence behaviour but not body mass of Princess Parrots Polytelis alexandraeJournal of Ornithology, 2014
- Are grassland passerines especially susceptible to negative transmitter impacts?Wildlife Society Bulletin, 2011
- Is abdominal implantation of devices a good alternative to external attachment? A comparative study in Adélie penguinsJournal of Ornithology, 2010
- Guidelines for the instrumentation of wild birds and mammalsAnimal Behaviour, 2009