An advanced method for measuring the residual stress of deposited film utilizing laser spallation technique
Authors:
Open Access
- 31 January 2006
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Science and Technology of Advanced Materials
- Vol. 7 (1) , 90-96
Abstract
Residual stress of thin diamond films deposited by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method was measured using a new method for residual stress measurement we developed. Compressive residual stresses of CVD diamond films were determined from the height and diameter of protuberance of film delaminated by pulse laser spallation technique. We produced the protuberance with different diameter and height by changing the laser energy. Compressive stresses were calculated from the momentum balance of atmospheric pressure and internal compressive force of the film. The residual stress of the well-faceted diamond film was measured as −338±22 MPa and agreed well with the stress (−348±17 MPa) measured by the X-ray diffraction method. In three other polycrystalline diamond films with different grain structure, the compressive stresses decreased from 300 to 147 MPa with decreasing the grain size from a few microns to tens of nanometers. Small compressive stresses of fine grain films are correlated with the grain boundary structure according to visible Raman spectra study conducted. Keywords Laser spallation Residual stress CVD diamond film Grain boundary structure 1 Introduction Residual stress of surface films deposited by chemical and physical vapor deposition method (CVD and PVD) causes film damages such as deformation, decohesion and often leads to the deterioration of functionality of the film. For the titanium nitride or diamond coated cutting tools produced by CVD method, both the adhesion strength and residual stress determine the reliability and life of the products. Quantitative measurement of the strength and residual stress are important for the optimization of the deposition condition. We previously developed a modified pulse laser spallation method to measure the adhesive strength of the film. Here, a strong expansion pulse wave was produced by the break-down of a confined oil layer on the opposite surface of the film substrate and produced a small delamination. Adhesion strength can be determined from the particle velocity of the film at the threshold pulse laser energy to cause a small delamination. Recently, we found that the delamination generated protuberance caused by compressive residual stress in the film. Residual stress can be measured from both the height and diameter of a relatively large protuberance. This method can measure the residual stress without knowing the elastic property of the film and is applicable to the film with poor crystallinity, to which conventional X-ray diffraction method cannot be used. Residual stresses of thin diamond films have been evaluated so far by the curvature method [1–3] , X-ray diffraction (XRD) [4–6] and Raman peak shift method [7–10] . These methods, however, possess following problems. The curvature method cannot be used when the substrate is deformed at high deposition temperatures [1] . XRD method needs a sufficient number of diffraction peaks over high diffraction angles, but such peaks are absent for strongly textured films and thin films. The method utilizing the Raman peak shift is not applicable for the nanometer-sized polycrystalline diamond film, to which sharp peaks cannot be obtained. The method we utilize in this report is an application of laser spallation technique [12,13] and is free from any problems of the conventional methods. It can measure the compressive residual stress of extremely thin films with strong epitaxiality or poor crystallinity. The adhesion strength or residual stress of the deposited film can be measured by producing an extremely small or a relatively large protuberance, respectively. 2 Experimental and analysis procedure 2.1 Pulse laser spallation to produce the delamination Pulse laser spallation was originally proposed by Vossen [11] to measure the adhesive strength of coated or deposited film in a non-contact manner. We previously, modified this method so as to produce strong expansion pulse wave. Fig. 1 (a) shows the modified laser spallation method [12,13] . Spallation or delamination of the film is induced by a strong expansion stress wave produced by break-down of an energy-absorbing layer (silicone grease containing MoS 2 particles) confined on the opposite surface of the film substrate. The break-down was induced by a high-energy Q-switched Nd:YAG laser (New Wave Research, Tempest 300, maximum energy, 300 mJ; pulse duration, 3–5 ns; wavelength, 1064 nm). We succeeded in producing the large expansion wave to produce a film delamination as shown in (b). For the adhesive strength of the film ( σ ad ), we measured the out-of-plane displacement ( u ) by a laser interferometer at the critical laser energy to cause a first small delamination. The adhesive strength of the film was computed by Eq. (1) . Detail of this method can be found elsewhere [12] , (1) σ ad = − ρ V l ∂ u ( t ) ∂ t where ρ is the density of the medium and V l denotes the velocity of the longitudinal wave. ρ and V l of sintered SiC substrate are taken as 3150 kg/m 3 and 11,803 m/s, respectively. For the residual stress measurement, we produced relatively large delamination with diameter from 1 to 2 mm by increasing the laser energy. Delaminated film bulged out by compressive residual stress. Three-dimensional shape of the protuberance was measured by a scanning laser interferometer at the vertical resolution of 0.1 nm. The height was generally in the range 250–700 nm, and small compared to the diameter of protuberance. 2.2 Specimen Polycrystalline diamond films were deposited by hot filament CVD method using gas of CH 4 /N 2 /H 2 mixture on disc-shaped sintered SiC substrate with a diameter of 25.4 mm and thickness of 6 mm. Prior to the deposition operation, substrate surface were scratched using a diamond wheel with particle size of 74 μm to obtain a good adhesion of the film by mechanical anchor effect. Average surface roughness...Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluation of Adhesive Strength of Chemical Vapor Deposition Diamond Films by Laser SpallationJapanese Journal of Applied Physics, 2004
- An elastic/plastic analysis of the intrinsic stresses in chemical vapor deposited diamond films on silicon substratesJournal of Applied Physics, 2000
- Calculation of intrinsic stress by creep deformation of an Si substrate on chemical vapor deposited diamond filmsDiamond and Related Materials, 2000
- Measurement of Residual Stress in Diamond Films Obtained Using Chemical Vapor DepositionJapanese Journal of Applied Physics, 1998
- Stress mapping of chemical-vapor-deposited diamond film surface by micro-Raman spectroscopyApplied Physics Letters, 1997
- Intrinsic stress and its relaxation in diamond film deposited by hot filament chemical vapor depositionJournal of Vacuum Science & Technology A, 1996
- Studies of stress related issues in microwave CVD diamond on 〈100〉 silicon substratesThin Solid Films, 1992
- Stress in thick diamond films deposited on siliconApplied Physics Letters, 1991
- Spatially resolved Raman studies of diamond films grown by chemical vapor depositionPhysical Review B, 1991
- Characterization of diamond films by Raman spectroscopyJournal of Materials Research, 1989