When research does not synchronize: Comprehensive analyses show no mother–child physiological coupling
Preprint
- 7 January 2026
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
Biobehavioral synchrony refers to covariation in physiological signals between interacting partners and is widely hypothesized to support co-regulation, bonding, and early socio-emotional development. This assumption is particularly salient for children born preterm, who often experience reduced early physical contact and prolonged neonatal separation, potentially shaping later caregiver–child attunement. Here we present a large-scale, systematic investigation of mother–child physiological synchrony in 102 dyads (70 preterm 5-year-olds and 32 matched full-term controls). Heart rate was recorded across eight interaction paradigms spanning passive viewing to face-to-face play. We applied the major commonly used analytic approaches, combined with rigorous surrogate-data controls and multiverse analyses, to assess the robustness of synchrony estimates. Across all paradigms, metrics, and analytic variants, synchrony in real dyads never exceeded that observed in pair-shuffled or segment-shuffled surrogate data. Patterns were virtually identical in full-term and preterm groups, and no reliable variability in synchrony remained that could be related to indices of prematurity. Together, these findings challenge the view that autonomic synchrony is a robust or ubiquitous feature of early social interaction and reveal substantial methodological fragility in current synchrony research. Our results underscore the need for more rigorous analytical frameworks and raise critical questions about when - and whether - physiological synchrony genuinely emerges in caregiver–child relationships.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Multimodal interpersonal synchrony: Systematic review and meta-analysisBehavioural Brain Research, 2024
- Beyond single paradigms, pipelines, and outcomes: Embracing multiverse analyses in psychophysiologyInternational Journal of Psychophysiology, 2024
- Proximity and touch are associated with neural but not physiological synchrony in naturalistic mother-infant interactionsNeuroImage, 2021
- Parent–child physiological synchrony: Concurrent and lagged effects during dyadic laboratory interactionDevelopmental Psychobiology, 2021
- A method for measuring dynamic respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA) in infants and mothersInfant Behavior and Development, 2021
- Synchrony of Respiratory Sinus Arrhythmia in Parents and Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: Moderation by Interaction Quality and Child Behavior ProblemsAutism Research, 2020
- Parents Mimic and Influence Their Infant’s Autonomic State through Dynamic Affective State MatchingCurrent Biology, 2019
- A systematic review of parent–child synchrony: It is more than skin deepDevelopmental Psychobiology, 2018
- Family stress moderates relations between physiological and behavioral synchrony and child self‐regulation in mother–preschooler dyadsDevelopmental Psychobiology, 2015
- Mother and infant coordinate heart rhythms through episodes of interaction synchronyInfant Behavior and Development, 2011