Further Thoughts on Aptitude/ Achievement Discrepancy
Authors:
- Keith E. StanovichKSKeith E. Stanovich
- Paula J. StanovichPSPaula J. Stanovich
- 1 April 1997
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Educational Psychology in Practice
- Vol. 13 (1) , 3-8
Abstract
We react to the recent commentaries on discrepancy definitions of reading disability by Frederickson and Reason (1995), Ashton (1996), and Solity (1996). We clarify many of the arguments in our earlier writings on the subject (Stanovich, 1991; 1994; Stanovich and Stanovich, 1996). Over a decade ago, when we started writing on this issue, there was little evidence indicating that poor readers of high and low IQ differed importantly in the primary processing mechanisms that were the cause of their reading failure. A further decade's worth of empirical work on this issue has still failed to produce such evidence. In the research community, the idea that aptitude/ achievement discrepancy tells us anything important about the processing mechanisms underlying reading difficulties is becoming untenable. The progress in understanding reading and reading failure that has been made is virtually orthogonal to the issue of reading/IQ discrepancy (see Shaywitz, 1996).Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Discrepancy Definitions of DyslexiaEducational Psychology in Practice, 1996
- In Defence of Discrepancy Definitions of Specific Learning DifficultiesEducational Psychology in Practice, 1996
- Components of phonological awarenessReading and Writing, 1995
- Discrepancy Definitions of Specific Learning DifficultiesEducational Psychology in Practice, 1995
- DysrationaliaJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1993
- Word recognition: The interface of educational policies and scientific researchReading and Writing, 1993
- A Reading Level Match Study of Nonword Reading Skills in Poor Readers with Varying IQJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1992
- Single‐word reading in college dyslexicsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 1992
- Reading processes in specific reading retarded and reading backward 13‐year‐oldsBritish Journal of Developmental Psychology, 1988
- Decoding, Reading, and Reading DisabilityRemedial and Special Education, 1986