Extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy or ureteroscopy as primary treatment for ureteric stones: a retrospective study comparing two different treatment strategies
Authors:
- 1 January 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Scandinavian Journal of Urology and Nephrology
- Vol. 40 (2) , 113-118
Abstract
Our extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy (ESWL) lithotripter with ultrasound localization technique was replaced in 1999 by a Storz SLX-MX lithotripter with both X-ray and ultrasound detection possibilities. Before replacing our lithotripter, most ureteric stones were treated with ureteroscopy (URS); subsequently, almost all patients underwent ESWL as primary treatment. The aim of this retrospective study was to compare the results of these two treatment strategies in all consecutive patients attending our hospital in 1998 and 2000 for ureteric stone treatment. The medical records of all patients treated for ureteric stones in 1998 and 2000 were reviewed. In 1998, 173 ureteric stones were treated. Primary treatment was URS in 124 patients, push back/ESWL in 24, ESWL in 21 and open surgery in four. In 2000, 176 ureteric stones were treated: 158 with ESWL and 18 with URS. ESWL or URS monotherapy was defined as ESWL or URS, respectively as the only stone-treatment therapy, with or without the use of a ureteric catheter or nephrostomy tube. Treatment success was defined as a stone-free ureter. In 1998, the success rate for URS monotherapy was 95%, with a retreatment rate (sessions per stone situation) of 1.06. Corresponding figures for ESWL monotherapy in 2000 were 90% and 1.69. All URS patients received general anaesthesia; ESWL patients received opiods. Complication rates were 6% for URS and 3% for ESWL. In the URS group, 4/8 complications were considered to be major. ESWL should be considered the first-line treatment for ureteric stones because of its non-invasive nature, lack of a requirement for general anaesthesia and low complication rates.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- PROSPECTIVE RANDOMIZED TRIAL COMPARING SHOCK WAVE LITHOTRIPSY AND URETEROSCOPY FOR MANAGEMENT OF DISTAL URETERAL CALCULIJournal of Urology, 2001
- Guidelines on Urolithiasis1European Urology, 2001
- EXTRACORPOREAL SHOCK WAVE LITHOTRIPSY VERSUS URETEROSCOPY FOR DISTAL URETERAL CALCULI: A PROSPECTIVE RANDOMIZED STUDYJournal of Urology, 1999
- Management of upper urinary tract calculi with ureteroscopic techniquesUrology, 1999
- Primary Endoscopic Treatment of Ureteric CalculiEuropean Urology, 1999
- CURRENT INDICATIONS FOR OPEN STONE SURGERY IN THE TREATMENT OF RENAL AND URETERAL CALCULIJournal of Urology, 1998
- URETERAL STONES CLINICAL GUIDELINES PANEL SUMMARY REPORT ON THE MANAGEMENT OF URETERAL CALCULIJournal of Urology, 1997
- Distal ureteral calculi: Ureteroscopy vs. ESWL. A prospective analysisInternational Urology and Nephrology, 1996
- Management of Ureteric StonesEuropean Urology, 1994
- Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy of Stones in the Mid UreterJournal of Urology, 1989