Reply to the ‘Comment on “What resources do high school students activate to link energetic and structural changes in chemical reactions? – A qualitative study”’ by K. S. Taber, Chem. Educ. Res. Pract. , 2024, 25 , https://doi.org/10.1039/D3RP00232B
- 7 June 2024
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Chemistry Education Research and Practice
- Vol. 25 (3) , 958-965
Abstract
Our article “What resources do high school students activate to link energetic and structural changes in chemical reactions? – A qualitative study” was recently commented on by Keith Taber. In his comment he focuses on the dominant role of the octet rule in students' reasoning and suggests that students rely on an octet framework. In the first part of this response, Taber's argument about the pervasive inappropriate use of the octet rule is supported by empirical evidence. Re-analysis of the data confirms that students often seem to assume initial atomicity, use anthropomorphic language, and closely associate the octet rule with stability. These points make the octet rule a convenient answer for students to fill the “explanatory vacuum” often left in chemistry education, e.g. for explaining the driving force of reactions. In the second part, we discuss how these observations might be rationalized. Rather than a static misconception perspective, we suggest that student's application of the octet rule can be viewed from a dynamic, resource-oriented view of learning. Three examples are introduced to illustrate the variety in students’ applications of the octet rule. For a better understanding, more detailed research on how students really think and learn about the octet rule and energetics is necessary.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- “I think of it that way and it helps me understand”: Anthropomorphism in elementary students' mechanistic storiesScience Education, 2024
- Exploring new depths: Applying machine learning for the analysis of student argumentation in chemistryJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2023
- Students’ Strategies, Struggles, and Successes with Mechanism Problem Solving in Organic Chemistry: A Scoping Review of the Research LiteratureJournal of Chemical Education, 2022
- A Review of Research on the Teaching and Learning of Chemical BondingJournal of Chemical Education, 2022
- You Are What You Assess: The Case for Emphasizing Chemistry on Chemistry AssessmentsJournal of Chemical Education, 2021
- A Friendly Introduction to “Knowledge in Pieces”: Modeling Types of Knowledge and Their Roles in Learning2018
- Allgemeine und Anorganische Chemie2016
- Defining Conceptual Understanding in General ChemistryJournal of Chemical Education, 2015
- A History of Conceptual Change Research2014
- A Common Core to Chemical Conceptions: Learners’ Conceptions of Chemical Stability, Change and Bonding2013