Association between Clinical Simulation Design Features and Novice Healthcare Professionals’ Cognitive Load: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Open Access
- 21 August 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Simulation & Gaming
- Vol. 53 (5) , 538-563
Abstract
Background: Clinical simulations are complex educational interventions characterized by several design features, which have the potential to influence cognitive load, that is, the mental effort required to assimilate new information and learn. This systematic review and meta-analysis explored the associations between simulation design features and cognitive load in novice healthcare professionals. Methods: Based on the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology, a search was performed in five databases for quantitative studies in which the cognitive load of novice healthcare professionals was measured during or after a simulation activity. Each clinical simulation was coded to describe its design features. Univariate and multivariate mixed model analyses were performed to explore the associations between simulation design features and cognitive load. Results: From 962 unique records, 45 studies were included and 27 provided enough data on subjective cognitive load (i.e., Paas Scale and NASA-Task Load Index scores) to be meta-analyzed. In the multivariate analysis for the NASA-Task Load Index scores, each repetition of a simulation using the same scenario resulted in a linear decrease in cognitive load. In contrast, technology-based instruction before or during a simulation activity was associated with higher cognitive load. In the univariate analyses, other features such as feedback and instructor presence were also statistically associated with cognitive load. Regarding the univariate analyses of the Paas Scale scores, simulator type, briefing, debriefing, and repetitive practice were statistically associated with cognitive load. Conclusion: This is the first meta-analysis exploring the relationship between clinical simulation design features and novice healthcare professionals’ cognitive load. Although the findings show that several design features can potentially increase or decrease cognitive load, several gaps and inconsistencies in the current literature make it difficult to appreciate how such reciprocity influences novice healthcare professionals’ learning. These limitations are discussed and avenues for educators and further research are suggested.Keywords
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparative effectiveness of instructional design features in simulation-based education: Systematic review and meta-analysisMedical Teacher, 2012
- Development and Validation of a Surgical Workload Measure: The Surgery Task Load Index (SURG‐TLX)World Journal of Surgery, 2011
- Cognitive Load Theory: How Many Types of Load Does It Really Need?Educational Psychology Review, 2011
- Effects of mental workload on nurses' visual behaviors during infusion pump operationJapan Journal of Nursing Science, 2010
- Higher Mental Workload is Associated With Poorer Laparoscopic Performance as Measured by the NASA-TLX ToolSimulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 2010
- Coordinating Progressive Levels of Simulation Fidelity to Maximize Educational BenefitAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Do novices display automaticity during simulator training?The American Journal of Surgery, 2008
- Debriefing with Good Judgment: Combining Rigorous Feedback with Genuine InquiryAnesthesiology Clinics, 2007
- Cognitive Load Measurement as a Means to Advance Cognitive Load TheoryEducational Psychologist, 2003
- Training strategies for attaining transfer of problem-solving skill in statistics: A cognitive-load approach.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1992