Technology Readiness Level of biodiversity monitoring with molecular methods – where are we on the road to routine implementation?
Authors:
- Tiina LaamanenTLTiina Laamanen
- Veera NorrosVNVeera Norros
- Petteri VihervaaraPVPetteri Vihervaara
- Jacqueline JerneyJJJacqueline Jerney
- Pirkko KortelainenPKPirkko Kortelainen
- Katharina KujalaKKKatharina Kujala
- Stefan LambertSLStefan Lambert
- Janne MäyräJMJanne Mäyrä
- Lilja NikulaLNLilja Nikula
- Ida PalmroosIPIda Palmroos
- Mikko TolkkinenMTMikko Tolkkinen
- Kristiina VuorioKVKristiina Vuorio
Preprint
- 16 July 2024
- preprint
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in ARPHA Preprints
- Vol. 5, e132214
Abstract
Human activities are causing rapid biodiversity loss across ecosystems, affecting human wellbeing and crucial ecosystem services. Traditional biodiversity monitoring tools cannot keep up with the increasing demands of monitoring due to their limited spatial or temporal coverage, high costs, and lack of taxonomic expertise. Thus, implementation of novel molecular monitoring methods (MoMs) such as environmental DNA (eDNA) and DNA metabarcoding, are necessary. MoMs offer significant benefits for biodiversity monitoring and environmental assessment: high sensitivity and accuracy, non-invasive sampling, broad taxonomic range and cost and time efficiency. However, the diverse methodological approaches within MoMs lead to poor comparability between studies and surveys, highlighting the need for standardized assessments. We used the Technology Readiness Level (TRL) framework to evaluate the maturity of MoMs, providing a structured assessment of their readiness for routine use. In a systematic literature review 420 articles fulfilling the study criteria were assessed and both individual studies and method categories ranked according to the TRL scale. The findings revealed a growing number of studies, particularly in aquatic environments, with most studies validating MoM technologies on a small scale but lacking large-scale system demonstrations. Aquatic eDNA-based methods targeting fish showed overall higher technology readiness compared to other sample types and taxa, and applications of MoMs ranked into the highest TRL were predominantly freshwater studies. Key barriers to the broader implementation of MoMs to monitoring include the need for international standards, better quantitative estimates, and comprehensive reference libraries. National and international cooperation is crucial for establishing common standards, ensuring reliable and comparable results, and expediting the routine use of MoMs in biodiversity monitoring. Recent efforts towards international standardization are encouraging, but further coordinated actions are necessary for the global implementation and acceptance of these methods.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Metabarcoding and Metagenomics, 9, e130834.
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward a national eDNA strategy for the United StatesEnvironmental DNA, 2023
- Balanced readiness level assessment (BRLa): A tool for exploring new and emerging technologies.Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2021
- Capturing open ocean biodiversity: Comparing environmental DNA metabarcoding to the continuous plankton recorderMolecular Ecology, 2020
- Detection of the rare Australian endemic blind cave eel (Ophisternon candidum) with environmental DNA: implications for threatened species management in subterranean environmentsHydrobiologia, 2020
- Online tools supporting the conduct and reporting of systematic reviews and systematic maps: a case study on CADIMA and review of existing toolsEnvironmental Evidence, 2018
- Assessing ecological status with diatoms DNA metabarcoding: Scaling-up on a WFD monitoring network (Mayotte island, France)Ecological Indicators, 2017
- Development of a sensitive detection method to survey pelagic biodiversity using eDNA and quantitative PCR: a case study of devil ray at seamountsMarine Biology, 2017
- Environmental DNA – An emerging tool in conservation for monitoring past and present biodiversityBiological Conservation, 2015