Integrating Multi-Disciplinary Expertise in a Learning and Adaptive European Pandemic Preparedness System - Development of a Conceptual Causal Loop Diagram
The COVID-19 pandemic functioned as a stress test for the EU health emergency framework, showing that pandemic preparedness depends not only on epidemiological dynamics but also on how institutions detect, interpret, and act on emerging threats. This research aims to improve understanding of how epidemic signals are translated into timely decisions and interventions across national and European levels. To this end, we develop and pre-validate a conceptual Causal Loop Diagram (CLD) that captures feedback processes linking pathogen spread, surveillance, threat assessment, risk perception, behavioral adaptation, health-system capacity, and governance response within the EU health emergency system. The CLD reflects both national response dynamics and EU-level coordination mechanisms and provides the foundation for a future System Dynamics simulation model. We used a multi-method approach combining a scoping review of peer-reviewed literature, a targeted review of grey literature, and semi-structured expert interviews. Evidence was synthesized into variables, causal relationships, and reinforcing and balancing feedback loops, organized around the Hazard–Exposure–Vulnerability framework and the distinction between actual and perceived risk. The resulting CLD identifies mechanisms that can amplify epidemic spread and system strain, including cryptic transmission, healthcare overload, misinformation, and socioeconomic erosion of compliance. It also maps stabilizing processes operating through surveillance, non-pharmaceutical interventions, healthcare response, vaccination, telehealth, and collective behavioral change. The findings show that governance, although often absent from epidemic models used for decision-making, is a dynamic component of pandemic systems. Coordination, decision delays, resource mobilization, communication quality, trust, and policy legitimacy shape whether epidemic signals are translated into timely collective action. The CLD offers a theory-building foundation for future simulation and supports the design of more adaptive, learning-oriented pandemic preparedness systems.