Abstract
In a well-conducted systematic review, Lowthian et al. [1] have reminded us that there is a paucity of good quality evidence to guide the care for frail older people attending Emergency Departments. Their review focussed on trials of transitional care models to support frail older people being discharged from EDs in six different countries; notably, all of the trials were at least 5 years old. The review authors rightly raise questions about methodology—are we targeting the right people with the right interventions, and are we measuring the right outcomes? Certainly all for the studies looked at vulnerable older people and the interventions were based upon comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA), which remains the best evidenced care model for frail older people [2], at least for inpatient care. But what about the outcomes available for analysis? These almost exclusively focussed upon service-related outcomes—short- and long-term admissions or readmissions. This focus is understandable, as there are few healthcare systems that do not place patient flow (bed-days) as an overarching priority. This focus is partly in response to operational pressures, but also motivated by concerns that congestion in the ED (which is driven by overall resource use, i.e. bed-days) is associated with adverse patient outcomes [3]. Service developments struggle to gather individual patient-related outcomes that can be meaningfully analysed, and formal research in urgent care is challenging to conduct. Nevertheless, resource use is not a patient-related outcome: the danger is that in pursuit of metrics that will be relevant from the operational perspective, we risk forgetting that the primary purpose of the hospital is to save lives and get people better. A different set of outcomes are required, focussing on areas such as quality of life, improvements in function and cognition.

This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit: