A Scoping Review and Guidelines on Privacy Policy's Visualization from an HCI Perspective
Authors:
- Shuning ZhangSZShuning Zhang
- Eve HeEHEve He
- Sixing TaoSTSixing Tao
- Yuting YangYYYuting Yang
- Ying MaYMYing Ma
- Ailei WangAWAilei Wang
- Xin YiXYXin Yi
- Hewu LiHLHewu Li
Preprint
Abstract
Privacy Policies are a cornerstone of informed consent, yet a persistent gap exists between their legal intent and practical efficacy. Despite decades of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) research proposing various visualizations, user comprehension remains low, and designs rarely see widespread adoption. To understand this landscape and chart a path forward, we synthesized 65 top-tier papers using a framework adapted from the user-centered design lifecycle. Our analysis presented findings of the field's evolution across four dimensions: (1) the trade-off between information load and decision efficacy, which demonstrates a shift from augmenting disclosures to prioritizing information condensation and cognitive load management to counter the inefficacy of comprehensive texts, (2) the co-evolutionary dynamic of design and automation, revealing that complex design ambitions such as context-awareness drove the need for advanced NLP, while recent LLM breakthroughs are enabling the semantic interpretation required to realize those designs, (3) the tension between generality and specificity, highlighting the divergence between standardized, cross-platform solutions and the increasing necessity for specialized, context-aware interaction patterns in IoT and immersive environments, and (4) balancing stakeholder opinions, which shows that visualization efficacy is constrained by the complex interplay of regulatory mandates, developer capabilities and provider incentives. We conclude by outlining four critical challenges for future research.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mental Model-Based Designs: The Study in Privacy Policy LandscapeInternational Journal of Human–Computer Interaction, 2024
- Large language models: a new approach for privacy policy analysis at scaleComputing, 2024
- Enhancing privacy policy comprehension through Privacify: A user-centric approach using advanced language modelsComputers & Security, 2024
- Designing for privacy: Exploring the influence of affect and individual characteristics on users' interactions with privacy policiesComputers & Security, 2023
- A systematic mapping study on automated analysis of privacy policiesComputing, 2022
- Digital technologies: tensions in privacy and dataJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2022
- Privacy and Vulnerable Populations2022
- Which Privacy Policy Works, Privacy Assurance or Personalization Declaration? An Investigation of Privacy Policies and Privacy ConcernsJournal of Business Ethics, 2020
- Engineering Privacy by Design: Are engineers ready to live up to the challenge?The Information Society, 2019
- “I agree to the terms and conditions”: (How) do users read privacy policies online? An eye-tracking experimentComputers in Human Behavior, 2016