Beyond the entry effect: The impact of competition intensity on high-speed rail prices
Preprint
- 23 July 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Open-access competition is rapidly reshaping European high-speed rail (HSR) markets, yet little is known about how competitive pressure affects pricing once entry has occurred. We address this gap by examining how changes in competitors' presence affect average fares and fare dispersion of the incumbent. We exploit the case of Spain, where liberalization was rolled out through a regulated capacity-allocation process, resulting in a market served by three operators offering four HSR products. Using monthly product-route transaction data from the Trainline booking platform covering January 2023 to July 2024, we estimate reduced-form fare models for more than 70 markets, distinguishing between the extensive and intensive margins of competition. We find that stronger competition exerts downward pressure on incumbent fares while increasing fare dispersion, with both effects reaching 25% in four-product markets relative to monopoly markets. Fare reductions are largely driven by independent entrants, whose competitive effects are broadly comparable despite their different business models, although weaker on routes where the incumbent also provides high-speed services at fixed fares. However, greater fare dispersion emerges when competition comes from rivals operating in the same market segment as the incumbent. While more price-sensitive passengers benefit from lower fares, travelers with a higher willingness to pay for service quality may continue to face relatively high prices.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- The third phase of the liberalisation of European long-distance passenger railwaysEuropean Transport Studies, 2026
- Competition models and financial sustainability of high-speed open-access passengers rail operators in EuropeEuropean Transport Studies, 2024
- The evaluation of competition effect on rail fares using the difference-in-difference method through symmetric and lagged spansJournal of Rail Transport Planning & Management, 2024
- Open access passenger rail competition in Slovakia – Experience from the Bratislava–Košice lineJournal of Rail Transport Planning & Management, 2019
- The effect of open access competition on average rail prices. The case of Milan – AnconaJournal of Rail Transport Planning & Management, 2016
- A model of internal and external competition in a High Speed Rail lineEconomics of Transportation, 2015
- Measuring the substitution effects between High Speed Rail and air transport in SpainJournal of Transport Geography, 2015
- Competition and cooperation between high-speed rail and air transportation services in EuropeJournal of Transport Geography, 2015
- Governance of competition and performance in European railways: An analysis of five casesUtilities Policy, 2014
- Interpreting semilogarithmic regression coefficients in labor researchJournal of Labor Research, 1989