Claiming and displaying national identity: Irish Travellers’ and students’ strategic use of ‘banal’ and ‘hot’ national identity in talk
- 16 April 2012
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Social Psychology
- Vol. 52 (3) , 450-468
Abstract
Two complementary explanations have been offered by social psychologists to account for the universal hold of national identity, first that national identity is ideologically assumed, as it forms the ‘banal’ background of everyday life, and second that national identity is ‘hotly’ constructed and contested in political and everyday settings to great effect. However, ‘banal’ and ‘hot’ aspects of national identity have been found to be distributed unevenly across national and subnational groups and banality itself can be strategically used to distinguish between different groups. The present paper develops these ideas by examining possible reasons for these different modes and strategies of identity expression. Drawing upon intergroup theories of minority and majority relations, we examine how a group who see themselves unequivocally as a minority, Irish Travellers, talk about their national identity in comparison to an age and gender‐matched sample of Irish students. We find that Travellers proactively display and claim ‘hot’ national identity in order to establish their Irishness. Irish students ‘do banality’, police the boundaries and reputation of Irishness, and actively reject and disparage proactive displays of Irishness. The implications for discursive understandings of identity, the study of intra‐national group relations and policies of minority inclusion are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identity, Banal Nationalism, Contestation, And North American License Plates*Geographical Review, 2011
- Enacting national concerns: Anglo‐British accounts of the 2002 Royal Golden JubileeJournal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 2010
- Socio‐political context and accounts of national identity in adolescenceBritish Journal of Social Psychology, 2010
- Devolution and national identity: the rules of English (dis)engagementNations and Nationalism, 2010
- The Banal National Party: the routine nature of legitimacyPatterns of Prejudice, 2009
- Talking to ‘real’ South Africans: An Investigation of the Dilemmatic Nature of NationalismSouth African Journal of Psychology, 2005
- The Ingroup as Pars Pro Toto: Projection From the Ingroup Onto the Inclusive Category as a Precursor to Social DiscriminationPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2003
- On being peripheral: effects of identity insecurity on personal and collective self‐esteemEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2001
- A 'Countryside Bright with Cosy Homesteads': Irish Nationalism and the Cottage LandscapeNational Identities, 2001
- Visual ethnography: Using photography in qualitative researchQualitative Sociology, 1989