Toward a standardized statistical methodology comparing optimum nitrogen rates among management practices: A bootstrapping approach
Open Access
- 1 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Agricultural & Environmental Letters
- Vol. 6 (2) , e20045
Abstract
There are a range of approaches to compare differences between or among optimum nitrogen (N) fertilizer rates resulting from different management practices; however, this goal lacks statistical standardization. To provide the statistical rigor needed to give clear recommendations for greater or less N need based on specific management practices, we propose a bootstrapping approach that resamples residuals with replacement. While bootstrapping is not new to data processing in agronomic fields, we provide an example of how to conduct residual‐resampled bootstrapping with nonlinear regression to identify differences in response curves, optimum N rates, and maximum yields using the FertBoot package in R. Our example dataset provides clear evidence of the value of the bootstrapping approach, as it can aid in determining significant differences between even relatively small differences in optimum N rate. We encourage adoption of this approach as a way to accurately evaluate differences in optimum fertilizer levels between or among treatments to better inform future agronomic decision making.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nitrogen Fertilizer Optimization for Sugarbeet in the Red River Valley of North Dakota and MinnesotaAgronomy Journal, 2018
- Biomass Production and Carbon/Nitrogen Ratio Influence Ecosystem Services from Cover Crop MixturesAgronomy Journal, 2016
- Yields and Profitability during and after Transition in Organic Grain Cropping SystemsAgronomy Journal, 2014
- Testing hypotheses on shape and distribution of ecological response curvesEcological Modelling, 2010
- Discriminant analysis of biogeochemical indicators of nutrient enrichment in a Florida wetlandEuropean Journal of Soil Science, 2009
- Introduction to the Bootstrap WorldStatistical Science, 2003
- Bootstrap Methods and their Application1997
- Comparison of Models for Describing; Corn Yield Response to Nitrogen FertilizerAgronomy Journal, 1990
- Nonlinear Regression Analysis and Its Applications1988
- Bootstrap Methods: Another Look at the JackknifeThe Annals of Statistics, 1979