Re‐thinking policy and (multi‐level) governance failure: What went wrong and why in the reception of Ukrainian refugees in Italy?
Open Access
- 8 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Governance
- Vol. 37 (4) , 1391-1411
Abstract
Following the outbreak of the war in Ukraine and the arrival of 170,000 refugees, the already fragile Italian refugee system was forced to undergo major re‐structuring and expansion. Re‐organisation included the adoption of partially new multi‐level governance relationships, as well as political instruments. Despite the widespread positive attitude of public opinion toward the Ukrainian refugees and the bipartisan support for their reception, the outcome of the policy has been not in line with the goals the proponents set out to achieve. In fact, there have been delays, poor assistance to those who have offered to host, and, in the end, a partial waste of the economic and human resources which were devoted to the reception itself. The purpose of this article is to investigate the origin and development of the “vices” of this process, departing from the interpretive lens on policy and governance failure. Our findings consolidate the theoretical challenge to the reductive binary rhetoric on success and failure, and the classic view of failure confined to formulation and implementation. In addition, the article shows that multi‐level governance dynamics are strongly relevant in explaining the “vices” of policies, particularly highlighting the role, until now largely disregarded, of the latent conflicts between the actors involved. The study has benefited from 38 semi‐structured interviews with political actors, including third‐party organisations and public actors, the analysis of political documents, and local and national media.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Achilles' heels of governance: Critical capacity deficits and their role in governance failuresRegulation & Governance, 2015
- State failure, governance failure and policy failure: Exploring the linkagesPublic Policy and Administration, 2015
- How to see failure: Attempts by the Inspectorate of Education to detect and disarm failure in Dutch education policyPublic Policy and Administration, 2015
- What is policy failure? A primer to help navigate the mazePublic Policy and Administration, 2015
- Urban Multiculturalism beyond the ‘Backlash’: New Discourses and Different Practices in Immigrant Policies across European CitiesJournal of Intercultural Studies, 2015
- The two orders of governance failure: Design mismatches and policy capacity issues in modern governancePolicy and Society, 2014
- The lessons of failure: learning and blame avoidance in public policy-makingInternational Political Science Review, 2012
- Why migration policies failEthnic and Racial Studies, 2004
- The Politics of Blame AvoidanceJournal of Public Policy, 1986
- Two Faces of PowerAmerican Political Science Review, 1962