The Mind's Eye of the Adopter: Visual Stereotypes of Dogs and Cats

Authors:

Abstract
The influence of visual appearance on pet adoption is poorly understood, partially due to inconsistent findings. We examined visual biases in the appearance of dogs and cats using a novel data-driven method that leverages generative AI to visualize mental prototypes at both the individual and group levels. The results demonstrated both strong idiosyncratic preferences and shared, group-level consistencies, offering an explanation for previously reported inconsistencies. Importantly, we found that greater similarity between images of real shelter animals and the group prototypes of “adoptable” dogs and cats, as well as “friendly” dogs, was associated with a shorter time in the shelter before adoption. This study provides novel evidence for the interplay between idiosyncratic variation and shared biases in shaping visual stereotypes of companion animals.