Abstract
OPPOSING the Conservative-led government’s planned ‘modernising’ health reforms in 2011, Dr Mark Porter, the Chair of the British Medical Association’s hospital consultants committee, felt sufficiently confident of a popular understanding—or should it be misunderstanding?—of our past to proclaim, in a none too complimentary fashion, that the current National Health Service (NHS) shakeup risked taking health-care provision back to the ‘grim and unfair days of the 1930s and 40s’. The service would become, he argued, an ‘increasingly tattered safety net’. Patients would be denied care simply because ‘they cost too much to treat’: