Comparative Safety of Medications for Severe Agitation: A Geriatric Emergency Department Guidelines 2.0 Systematic Review
Open Access
- 24 April 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
- Vol. 73 (9) , 2893-2904
Abstract
Background: Managing undifferentiated, severe agitation in older adults may require antipsychotic or sedative medications to prevent harm to self or others. Unfortunately, these medications are associated with serious adverse events in older adults, and little is known about their comparative safety.Methods: We conducted a systematic review to identify comparative effectiveness studies on the safety of medications used in the treatment of severe agitation among older adults in the prehospital or emergency department (ED) setting. We searched eight databases including PubMed, EMBASE, SCOPUS, Cochrane library, CINAHL, Proquest Central, Ageline, and PsycInfo published in or before February 2024. Studies were included if they examined 1st generation antipsychotics, 2nd generation antipsychotics, benzodiazepines, or ketamine. Data were extracted on adverse respiratory events (apnea, hypoxemia, intubation) and other adverse events (arrhythmia, hypotension, worsening delirium, cardiac arrest, and mortality). We report the aggregate occurrence of any adverse events pooled by drug and report odds ratios (ORs) using haloperidol as the reference group.Results: Among 8600 studies identified, eight observational studies and one randomized clinical trial met eligibility for further qualitative and quantitative analysis. The observational studies included 838 older adults receiving haloperidol (n = 117), droperidol (n = 129), lorazepam (n = 350), midazolam (n = 68), olanzapine (n = 101), quetiapine (n = 56), and ziprasidone (n = 17). Any adverse events were observed in 16.8% of the patients (141/838). Adverse events were most common among patients receiving midazolam (53%; 36/68). Relative to haloperidol, midazolam significantly increased the risk for any adverse events (OR 5.25 [95% CI: 2.64–10.45]). Quetiapine was the only drug observed to have a lower frequency of adverse events (OR 0.27 [95% CI: 0.08, 0.97]).Conclusions: Adverse drug events are common among older adults receiving antipsychotic or anxiolytic medications for severe agitation. Benzodiazepines, particularly midazolam, pose an excessive risk to older adults requiring pharmacologic treatment for severe agitation.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Frailty assessment tools in the emergency department: A geriatric emergency department guidelines 2.0 scoping reviewJACEP Open, 2023
- Safety and effectiveness of benzodiazepines and antipsychotics for agitation in older adults in the emergency departmentThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2023
- The use of verbal de-escalation in intoxicated emergency department patientsThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2022
- Efficacy of ketamine for initial control of acute agitation in the emergency department: A randomized studyThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2021
- The agitated older adult in the emergency department: a narrative review of common causes and management strategiesJACEP Open, 2020
- The Characteristics and Prevalence of Agitation in an Urban County Emergency DepartmentAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2018
- Paradoxical reaction to benzodiazepines in elderly – Case seriesAsian Journal of Psychiatry, 2018
- A Prospective Observational Study of Patients Receiving Intravenous and Intramuscular Olanzapine in the Emergency DepartmentAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2017
- The Safety and Effectiveness of Droperidol for Sedation of Acute Behavioral Disturbance in the Emergency DepartmentAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2015
- Parenteral sedation of elderly patients with acute behavioral disturbance in the EDThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2013