A Comparison of Students' Problem Posing Under Different Task Conditions on Problem Validity and Mathematical Complexity
- 27 September 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in School Science and Mathematics
Abstract
This study examines how different task conditions influence the quality of seventh‐grade students' mathematical problem posing. The participants were 646 students from public middle schools who were assigned conditions: posing problems‐only or posing problems and solving the problems they generated. Students completed two semi‐structured problem‐posing tasks, one involving a growing pattern and the other a real‐life membership cost context. Student‐generated problems were analyzed using a two‐stage framework in which validity was evaluated based on whether problems were mathematical, aligned with the task context, and solvable, and mathematical complexity was examined according to the number of steps required for solution, with non‐solvable problems assigned a score of zero for group‐level comparisons. The results revealed consistent differences between the two conditions: students who only posed problems generated more valid and task‐appropriate problems and demonstrated higher levels of mathematical complexity across tasks and overall, whereas students who were required to both pose and solve problems obtained lower validity and complexity scores. These findings suggest that additional task requirements may alter the cognitive and procedural demands of problem‐posing activities, influencing the quality of students' generated problems. The findings further highlight the importance of considering task conditions when designing problem‐posing activities in middle‐school mathematics classrooms.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Advances in research on mathematical problem posing: Focus on task variablesThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2024
- Teaching mathematics through problem posing: Elements of the taskThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2024
- Middle Level Mathematics Teachers’ Problems on Linear Relationships in a Semi-Structured Problem Posing SituationRMLE Online, 2023
- Beyond small, medium, or large: points of consideration when interpreting effect sizesEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2019
- Pre-service teachers' free and structured mathematical problem posingInternational Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 2016
- Problem-Posing Research in Mathematics Education: Some Answered and Unanswered Questions2015
- Cognitive Load Theory2011
- Exploring Mathematical Creativity Using Multiple Solution Tasks2009
- The role of task format, mathematics knowledge, and creative thinking on the arithmetic problem posing of prospective elementary school teachersMathematics Education Research Journal, 1997
- Cognitive Load During Problem Solving: Effects on LearningCognitive Science, 1988