Incorporating non-climate externalities receiving public attention in the optimisation of grid decarbonisation: the case of Ontario
Open Access
- 19 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Environmental Research: Energy
- Vol. 2 (3) , 035007
Abstract
This paper extends a cost-optimising electricity capacity expansion model for the Canadian province of Ontario to incorporate several non-climate externalities, reflecting the way such externalities have been shown to impact the public acceptance of clean electricity policy. A Textometrica analysis of 225 news articles identified employment and health as the externalities receiving the most public attention, followed by land use and ecological impacts. Multiple sets of monetary valuations of the impact of different generation technologies on each externality were generated from the literature. The model was run with each combination of valuations incorporated into the cost function and with no externalities under both partial (carbon cost of $200 CAD/tonne) and full decarbonisation. Incorporating externalities was found to decrease optimal emissions by 21% on average across partial decarbonisation scenarios, and generally to increase optimal wind capacity expansion and retirement of gas generation (solar expansion and nuclear expansion were not optimal in any modelled scenario). Significantly, the incorporation of externalities only modestly increases the accounting cost of the system. All these impacts are much smaller in the case of full decarbonisation. Results are highly sensitive to the health impact valuations used and the presence of community support for wind expansion, which determines whether property values are impacted. Application of this modelling approach and these findings should not only reduce the social cost of electricity system decarbonisation measures but also facilitate their implementation by decreasing the risk of politicised opposition.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Clean Electricity, Dirty Electricity: The Effect on Local House PricesThe Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 2021
- Greening the Saskatchewan grid: A case study in deliberative energy modellingEcological Economics, 2021
- An integrated assessment framework for the decarbonization of the electricity generation sectorApplied Energy, 2021
- Life cycle assessment integration into energy system models: An application for Power-to-Methane in the EUApplied Energy, 2020
- State-of-the-art generation expansion planning: A reviewApplied Energy, 2018
- Framing low-carbon pathways: A discursive analysis of contending storylines surrounding the phase-out of coal-fired power in OntarioEnvironmental Innovation and Societal Transitions, 2018
- Exploring deep decarbonization pathways to 2050 for Canada using an optimization energy model frameworkApplied Energy, 2017
- A multi-period power generation planning model incorporating the non-carbon external costs: A case study of ChinaApplied Energy, 2016
- Incorporating environmental externalities into the capacity expansion planning: An Israeli case studyEnergy Conversion and Management, 2011
- Full-cost dispatch: Incorporating environmental externalities in electric system operationThe Electricity Journal, 1991