Gaps in the phenotype descriptions of ultra-rare genetic conditions: review and multicenter consensus reporting guidelines
Authors:
- Ali AlMailAAAli AlMail
- IPCHip Exectuve CommitteeICIPCHip Exectuve Committee
Preprint
Abstract
Background: Genome-wide sequencing and genetic matchmaker services are propelling a new era of genotype-first ascertainment of novel genetic conditions. The degree to which reported phenotype data in discovery-focused studies address informational priorities for clinicians and families is unclear. Methods: We identified reports published from 2017-2021 in ten genetics journals of novel Mendelian disorders ascertained genotype-first. We adjudicated the quality and detail of the phenotype data via 46 questions pertaining to six priority domains: (I) Development, cognition, and mental health; (II) Feeding and growth; (III) Medication use and treatment history; (IV) Pain, sleep, and quality of life; (V) Adulthood; and (VI) Epilepsy. For a subset of articles, all subsequent published follow-up case descriptions were identified and assessed in a similar manner. A modified Delphi approach was used to develop consensus reporting guidelines, with input from content experts across four countries. Results: In total, 200 of 3243 screened publications met inclusion criteria. Relevant phenotypic details across each of the six domains were rated superficial or deficient in >87% of papers. For example, less than 10% of publications provided details regarding neuropsychiatric diagnoses and behavioural issues, or about the type/nature of feeding problems. Follow-up reports (n=95) rarely addressed the limitations of the original reports. Reporting guidelines were developed for each domain. Conclusion: Phenotype information relevant to clinical management, genetic counseling, and the stated priorities of patients and families is lacking for many newly described genetic diseases. Use of the proposed guidelines could improve phenotype reporting in the genomic era.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- UBTF Mutation Causes Complex Phenotype of Neurodegeneration and Severe Epilepsy in ChildhoodNeuropediatrics, 2018
- Loss-of-function and gain-of-function mutations in PPP3CA cause two distinct disordersHuman Molecular Genetics, 2018
- De novo variants in CAMK2A and CAMK2B cause neurodevelopmental disordersAnnals of Clinical and Translational Neurology, 2018
- A recurrent de novo missense mutation in UBTF causes developmental neuroregressionHuman Molecular Genetics, 2018
- PhenoTips: Patient Phenotyping Software for Clinical and Research UseHuman Mutation, 2013
- Functional outcomes of adults with 22q11.2 deletion syndromeGenetics in Medicine, 2012
- New “first families”: the psychosocial impact of new genetic technologiesGenetics in Medicine, 2012
- Caregiver and adult patient perspectives on the importance of a diagnosis of 22q11.2 deletion syndromeJournal of Intellectual Disability Research, 2011
- An introduction to standardized clinical nomenclature for dysmorphic features: the Elements of Morphology projectBMC Medicine, 2010
- Guidance for Developers of Health Research Reporting GuidelinesPLOS Medicine, 2010