A comparative analysis of CAD modeling approaches for design solution space exploration
Authors:
Open Access
- 28 March 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Advances in Mechanical Engineering
- Vol. 16 (3)
Abstract
Design solution space (DSS) exploration is a pivotal process for comprehending design challenges and identifying diverse solution alternatives based on varying requirements. Computer-aided design (CAD) approaches, such as parametric design, knowledge-based design, and generative design, have proven successful in DSS exploration. However, a comparative study evaluating their performance is lacking in the technical literature. This paper addresses this gap by conducting a comparative analysis of these approaches regarding their performance in exploring DSS. The research begins by providing an overview of parametric design, knowledge-based design, and generative design, establishing the foundation for the study. Six evaluation criteria are identified based on the DSS exploration process. A qualitative analysis is then conducted, considering these criteria, to objectively assess the performance of each modeling approach. The results highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each approach, revealing that DSS exploration success is directly tied to the quantity of implemented knowledge. The results also emphasize the complementarity of those approaches, as their strengths and weaknesses are based on different problem-solving logics, demonstrating the synergy that can be achieved through strategic combinations of them. Additionally, the paper discusses open issues related to DSS exploration, contributing valuable insights for future developments in this field.Keywords
Funding Information
- Basic and Applied Basic Research Foundation of Guangdong Province (2022A1515110187)
- Southern Ocean Science and Engineering Guangdong Provincial Laboratory (Zhuhai) Independent Research Project (SML2022SP101)
- Scientific Research Project of Education Department of Guangdong Province (2022KCXTD029)
This publication has 74 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploiting the generative design potential to select the best conceptual design of an aerospace component to be produced by additive manufacturingThe International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2023
- Architecting A Knowledge-Based Platform for Design Engineering 4.02022
- Shape Grammars: A Key Generative Design Algorithm2021
- Knowledge-Based Design in Industrialised House Building: A Case-Study for Prefabricated Timber Walls2019
- Parametric modeling and multiobjective crashworthiness design optimization of a new front longitudinal beamStructural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, 2018
- CAx für Ingenieure2018
- Multidisciplinary Design Optimization Supported by Knowledge Based Engineering2015
- Requirements change in complex technical systems: an empirical study of root causesResearch in Engineering Design, 2014
- Supporting product architecture design using computational design synthesis with network structure constraintsResearch in Engineering Design, 2011
- A heuristic-based approach to conceptual designResearch in Engineering Design, 2008