We explore how consumption is closely related to the relational, materially mediated experience of technology through the design and deployment of speculative artefacts, and furthermore how the mediative properties of such artefacts may influence these outcomes. Analyses of cases developed within a postgraduate design course drew from postphenomenology to frame the relational intertwining through which humans, technologies and the environment are influencing one another in an ongoing process of change. Critical and speculative design methods were used to promote a deviation from dominant norms, and to explore novel ways of highlighting mediations in terms of everyday consumption. While the case studies have their own particularities, we suggest that they align in terms of their focus on materiality, and in their conscious depiction of alternative modes of consumption. The works represent a process of media exploration, field-deployment and exhibition-dissemination as a means by which to materialize, share and evaluate matters of concern. In conclusion, we highlight through exploratory case studies how design can challenge dominant imaginaries of consumption and cultural practices, and suggest postphenomenological perspectives as a rich philosophical and analytical lens with which to deepen development and understanding of speculative design proposals. The article aims to broaden the arguable need to support critical perspectives, through design, in pursuit of open-ended and more sustainable futures. Working through the material properties of speculative design provides tangible, situated, aesthetic opportunities to influence ongoing discussions regarding the interplay between design, technology and consumption.