Comparison of clinical outcomes and second-look arthroscopic findings after ACL reconstruction using a hamstring autograft or a tibialis allograft
- 30 December 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy
- Vol. 25 (4) , 1290-1297
Abstract
Purpose The purpose of this prospective randomized clinical study was to compare the clinical and radiological outcomes, including tibial tunnel widening and the progression of osteoarthritis after ACL reconstruction using a hamstring autograft or a tibialis allograft. In addition, we compared the graft tear and synovial coverage of grafts in patients that underwent the second-look arthroscopy. Methods Among 184 patients with an ACL injury who underwent ACL reconstruction, 68 patients of autograft group and 64 patients of tibialis allograft group were included for this study after minimum of 2-year follow-up. The Lachman and pivot-shift tests, Tegner activity score, Lysholm knee score, and IKDC score were compared between the two groups. The quadriceps and hamstring isokinetic strengths using dynamometer were also compared. Degree of OA was determined using the Kellgren–Lawrence grading system on the weight-bearing radiographs. In total, 51 patients (26 patients in autograft group and 25 in the tibialis allograft group) underwent the second-look arthroscopy, in which we compared the apparent tear of graft and synovial coverage of grafts. Results At the final follow-up, there were no statistical significances in the two groups in Lachman and pivot-shift tests (n.s.). The Tegner activity, Lysholm knee score, and IKDC scores were similar in the two groups. Moreover, no significant differences were observed in the muscle power (n.s.). Some patients showed the progression of OA (five in autograft and four in allograft groups) without intergroup difference (n.s.). Regarding the findings of second-look arthroscopy, although there was no significant difference in graft tear, synovial coverage was better in autograft group than in allograft group. Conclusion Even though hamstring autografts and tibialis allografts provided good functional outcomes without significant differences, the second-look arthroscopy revealed that hamstring autografts produced better synovial coverage than tibialis allograft. Level of evidence I.Keywords
Funding Information
- natioal research foundation of Korea (2014R1A1A2059147)
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Analysis of 16,192 Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstructions From a Community-Based RegistryThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2013
- Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with 4‐strand hamstring autograft and accelerated rehabilitation: a 10‐year prospective study on clinical results, knee osteoarthritis and its predictorsKnee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy, 2012
- Second-Look Arthroscopic Assessment of Arthroscopic Single-Bundle Posterior Cruciate Ligament ReconstructionThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2012
- Arthroscopic Reconstruction of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament With Hamstring Tendon Autograft and Fresh-Frozen AllograftThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2011
- In Vivo Stability and Clinical Comparison of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Using Low or High Femoral Tunnel PositionsThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2010
- Second‐Look Arthroscopic Evaluations of Anatomic Double‐Bundle Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Relation With Postoperative Knee StabilityArthroscopy, 2007
- A 10-Year Comparison of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstructions with Hamstring Tendon and Patellar Tendon AutograftThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2007
- Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: Which graft is best?Arthroscopy, 2004
- Allograft Versus Autograft Anterior Cruciate Ligament ReconstructionClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 1996
- Evaluation of hamstring strength following use of semitendinosus and gracilis tendons to reconstruct the anterior cruciate ligamentThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1982