How Would We Know What Works?
Authors:
- 1 July 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Evaluation
- Vol. 12 (3) , 294-312
Abstract
In 2002 the UK Home Office commissioned a review of research on community involvement in area-based initiatives. This found comparatively few studies that set out to measure the impact rather than the extent and nature of involvement and hence few answers to the question of what works. This article takes that finding as its starting point and sets out to develop a more robust framework for evaluating the impact of community involvement. It notes the difficulties inherent in using a classic experimental design to evaluate processes as complex as community involvement and proposes a theory-based approach. To this end, it critically reviews the underlying theoretical claims of both community involvement and of area-based initiatives. An evaluation framework is then developed in which the potential benefits of greater involvement are considered for each stage of the process of developing an area-based initiative and positive and negative contextual factors are identified.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Power to the People? How to Judge Public ParticipationLocal Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit, 2004
- Evidence, Understanding and ComplexityEvaluation, 2003
- From Knowing to DoingEvaluation, 2003
- Strong theory, flexible methods: Evaluating complex community-based initiativesCritical Public Health, 2001
- Public policy experimentation: Lessons from AmericaPolicy Studies, 1998
- Urban Policy and the Myth of ProgressPolicy & Politics, 1997
- Urban Policy: The Victory of Form over Substance?Urban Studies, 1997
- Evaluating a Community Crime Prevention ProgramEvaluation, 1997
- Empowerment evaluationEvaluation Practice, 1994
- Reforms as experiments.American Psychologist, 1969