Normative Ethics Does Not Need a Foundation: It Needs More Science
Open Access
- 21 April 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Acta Biotheoretica
- Vol. 59 (1) , 29-51
Abstract
The impact of science on ethics forms since long the subject of intense debate. Although there is a growing consensus that science can describe morality and explain its evolutionary origins, there is less consensus about the ability of science to provide input to the normative domain of ethics. Whereas defenders of a scientific normative ethics appeal to naturalism, its critics either see the naturalistic fallacy committed or argue that the relevance of science to normative ethics remains undemonstrated. In this paper, we argue that current scientific normative ethicists commit no fallacy, that criticisms of scientific ethics contradict each other, and that scientific insights are relevant to normative inquiries by informing ethics about the options open to the ethical debate. Moreover, when conceiving normative ethics as being a nonfoundational ethics, science can be used to evaluate every possible norm. This stands in contrast to foundational ethics in which some norms remain beyond scientific inquiry. Finally, we state that a difference in conception of normative ethics underlies the disagreement between proponents and opponents of a scientific ethics. Our argument is based on and preceded by a reconsideration of the notions naturalistic fallacy and foundational ethics. This argument differs from previous work in scientific ethics: whereas before the philosophical project of naturalizing the normative has been stressed, here we focus on concrete consequences of biological findings for normative decisions or on the day-to-day normative relevance of these scientific insights.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- CLASSICAL NATURAL LAW THEORY, PROPERTY RIGHTS, AND TAXATIONSocial Philosophy and Policy, 2010
- Mother–infant interactions in free-ranging rhesus macaques: Relationships between physiological and behavioral variablesPhysiology & Behavior, 2009
- Baby Schema in Infant Faces Induces Cuteness Perception and Motivation for Caretaking in AdultsEthology, 2009
- Genetic relatedness and sibling relationship characteristics in a modern societyEvolution and Human Behavior, 2007
- Females, food, family, and friendship2002
- The Temptations of Evolutionary Ethics.The American Historical Review, 1996
- The Object of MoralityCambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 1993
- Childhood Experience, Interpersonal Development, and Reproductive Strategy: An Evolutionary Theory of SocializationChild Development, 1991
- Childhood Experience, Interpersonal Development, and Reproductive Strategy: An Evolutionary Theory of SocializationChild Development, 1991
- Growth-Produced Changes in Body Shape and Size as Determinants of Perceived Age and Adult CaregivingChild Development, 1983