Exploring the post-genomic world: differing explanatory and manipulatory functions of post-genomic sciences
Open Access
- 2 January 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in New Genetics and Society
- Vol. 35 (1) , 49-68
Abstract
Richard Lewontin proposed that the ability of a scientific field to create a narrative for public understanding garners it social relevance. This article applies Lewontin's conceptual framework of the functions of science (manipulatory and explanatory) to compare and explain the current differences in perceived societal relevance of genetics/genomics and proteomics. We provide three examples to illustrate the social relevance and strong cultural narrative of genetics/genomics for which no counterpart exists for proteomics. We argue that the major difference between genetics/genomics and proteomics is that genomics has a strong explanatory function, due to the strong cultural narrative of heredity. Based on qualitative interviews and observations of proteomics conferences, we suggest that the nature of proteins, lack of public understanding, and theoretical complexity exacerbates this difference for proteomics. Lewontin's framework suggests that social scientists may find that omics sciences affect social relations in different ways than past analyses of genetics.Keywords
Funding Information
- Australia Awards (Endeavour Research Fellowship)
- Canadian Institutes of Health Research (111402)
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Biomarkers, the molecular gaze and the transformation of cancer survivorshipBioSocieties, 2013
- Walking the tightrope: Expectations and standards in personal genomicsBioSocieties, 2013
- Informed choice in direct-to-consumer genetic testing for Alzheimer and other diseases: lessons from two casesNew Genetics and Society, 2011
- Personal genomics and individual identities: motivations and moral imperatives of early usersNew Genetics and Society, 2010
- The psycho geneEMBO Reports, 2010
- Molecular medicine and concepts of disease: the ethical value of a conceptual analysis of emerging biomedical technologiesMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2009
- Perceptions of Familial Risk in those Seeking a Genetic Risk Assessment for Alzheimer's DiseaseJournal of Genetic Counseling, 2008
- Sociomics! Using the IssueCrawler to map, monitor and engage with the global proteomics research networkProteomics, 2005
- Extra chromosomes and blue tulips: medico-familial interpretations2000
- Authorizing Knowledge in Science and AnthropologyAmerican Anthropologist, 1998