Journal editors’ perspectives on the roles and tasks of peer reviewers in biomedical journals: a qualitative study
Open Access
Abstract
Objective Peer reviewers of biomedical journals are expected to perform a large number of roles and tasks, some of which are seemingly contradictory or demonstrate incongruities between the respective positions of peer reviewers and journal editors. Our aim was to explore the perspectives, expectations and understanding of the roles and tasks of peer reviewers of journal editors from general and specialty biomedical journals. Design Qualitative study. Setting Worldwide. Participants 56 journal editors from biomedical journals, most of whom were editors-in-chief (n=39), male (n=40) and worked part-time (n=50) at journals from 22 different publishers. Methods Semistructured interviews with journal editors were conducted. Recruitment was based on purposive maximum variation sampling. Data were analysed thematically following the methodology by Braun and Clarke. Results Journal editors’ understanding of the roles and partly of tasks of peer reviewers are profoundly shaped by each journal’s unique context and characteristics, including financial and human resources and journal reputation or prestige. There was a broad agreement among journal editors on expected technical tasks of peer reviewers related to scientific aspects, but there were different expectations in the level of depth. We also found that most journal editors support the perspective that authorship experience is key to high-quality reviews, while formal training in peer reviewing is not. Conclusion These journal editors’ accounts reveal issues of a social nature within the peer-review process related to missed opportunities for journal editors to engage with peer reviewers to clarify the expected roles and tasks. Further research is needed on actual performance of peer reviewers looking into the content of peer-reviewer reports to inform meaningful training interventions, journal policies and guidelines.Keywords
Funding Information
- H2020 Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (676207)
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bias in peer reviewJournal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2012
- Best peer reviewers and the quality of peer review in biomedical journalsCroatian Medical Journal, 2012
- Are Peer Reviewers Encouraged to Use Reporting Guidelines? A Survey of 116 Health Research JournalsPLOS ONE, 2012
- What do the JAMA editors say when they discuss manuscripts that they are considering for publication? Developing a schema for classifying the content of editorial discussionBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2007
- The Relationship of Previous Training and Experience of Journal Peer Reviewers to Subsequent Review QualityPLOS Medicine, 2007
- Why do peer reviewers decline to review? A surveyJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2006
- How Many Interviews Are Enough?Field Methods, 2006
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- Sample size in qualitative researchResearch in Nursing & Health, 1995
- Reviewer Status and Review QualityNew England Journal of Medicine, 1985